United States Forums

Start a new topic Change Forum
Advanced search

NYC Trip Report - Fodors 100 Contest Winner

Jump to last reply

NY Trip Report- Fodor’s 100 Winner

Ever wonder what it would be like to take a trip planned by real travel pros? My daughter and I recently returned from a four night stay in NY courtesy of Fodor’s.

You may have remembered a contest that ran during September 2012. Foderites could enter by submitting a hotel review. I submitted a review of the Atlanta Ritz Carlton where we had spent a night during the Labor Day Weekend. It was a fluke that we booked that hotel.

The review that I submitted for the contest is below:


They make great customer service look easy.

My famiy had their hearts set on attending the DragonCon parade. It was the same weekend in Atlanta as several major sports events. The whole city was booked up for twelve miles out. Low and behold the Ritz Carlton was available with Marriott points. It was directly on the parade route and blocks from the convention center.

Despite paying with points we were treated as royalty. We were offered bottled water or champagne at check in. There were cookies and custom M&Ms in the lobby. I was delighted that even though they were totally full, they honored our request for connecting rooms. The kids loved the I-pod dock and dimmable lights. My 13 year old tried on one of the fluffy white robes. My husband was amazed when he went to get ice and found the ice bucket had already been filled. (How did they do that?). I liked the plush bed and the fact that despite being filled with hundreds of sports fans and Klingon warriors the hotel was quiet.

It gets better. They gave us a 3 p.m checkout so we could enjoy ourselves and not rush. I want to go back. I don't know if I should buy lottery tickets or try to earn more Marriott points.

by palmettoprincess, 9/13/12



I have to admit, I thought that I would win. The entry deadline was my birthday which was a good omen. That being said I was still shocked to see the email from Fodor’s.

The dates of the trip were set for November At that time the hotel was still a secret. All I had to do was to select my travel companion. My husband was my first choice, but I knew it would be hard for both of us to get away during the school year. I thought of my college-aged daughter. She is studying graphic design and would love to meet the Fodor’s staff.

I had about month to plan the trip but for some reason I didn’t jump into my usual trip planning mod. I looked at getting tickets for plays but never hit “buy.” I tried on cocktail dresses for the Fodor’s 100 launch party, but didn’t find a favorite.

Of course I read the Fodor’s 2013 NY Guide from cover-to-cover but there was something off with my planning.

Sandy hit. I was dismayed at the devastation. Even those who were spared the wind and water struggled with power outages and gasoline shortages. I still wanted to go to New York but I didn’t want my first visit to the city to be under those conditions.

Fodor’s cancelled the Fodor’s 100 award ceremony because the event venue was damaged. They graciously allowed us to reschedule for my daughter’s spring break.

To Be Continued

15 Replies |Back to top

| Add a Reply

Sign in to comment.

Recent Activity

  • Announcement: Writers Needed for Croatia Guidebook
    by Emily_D Fodor's Editor | Posted on Apr 24, 14 at 05:34 PM
View all United States activity »
  1. 1 Trip Report Searching For The Rhythm Of Florida
  2. 2 Check List for a Sri Lankan Wedding
  3. 3 West coast and East coast trip for 18 days
  4. 4 Dim Sum and Pho in San Francisco
  5. 5 Chicago Architectural River Tours - which one for us?
  6. 6 Maui vacation
  7. 7 Chicago in early March 2015 - a dilemma...
  8. 8 Use of an iPad in France
  9. 9 New York City Taking First Steps Against Air BnB Members
  10. 10 New York City Restaurants
  11. 11 Hotel recommendation for San Francisco
  12. 12 Helicopter tours from Vegas to Grand Canyon
  13. 13 2 Days in Portland - Best of?
  14. 14 Where to stay with kids in Nashville
  15. 15 Cabin Honeymoon Out West
  16. 16 DRIVING ACROSS COUNTRY EAST TO WEST MID MAY TO JUNE
  17. 17 Dining Suggestions for the Baltimore/Annapolis Area?
  18. 18 Trip Report Trip Report: An Intoxicating Birthday Day-Trip in Napa
  19. 19 Boston/Fenway park
  20. 20 California self drive trip
  21. 21 Santa Fe advice needed (40th anniversary)
  22. 22 Boutique Hotels - NYC
  23. 23 Timeshare Nightmares
  24. 24 Glacier, Yellowstone, and Grand Teton itinerary - advice requested please!
  25. 25 10 day trip to California
View next 25 » Back to the top