United States Forums

Start a new topic Change Forum
Advanced search

Northern Spy and Defonte's

We ate at Northern Spy when it first opened and forgot how good it was. You can apply all the labels about local foods but it is not fussy but satisfying and appealing.

I had the turkey sandwich which sounds bland but they slather on Big Ed's cheese, onion-jalapeno marmalade, and aioli all is forgiven. There is a salad on the side.

Mrs. Adu had a purslane salad which was crisp and also topped with Big Ed's cheese. I wonder if his sister Muffet makes the curds and whey.

We split french fries that were cooked in duck fat, that were tender on the inside and crisp on the outside. Perfect.

It was crowded for a Friday lunch.

http://www.northernspyfoodco.com/

I have written about Defonte's before. It was in Red Hook, Brooklyn for 75 years before it opened an outpost on Third Ave and 21 Street in Manhattan. They make sandwiches and all the sandwiches taste like old Brooklyn. In fact one sandwich (sangwitch, a Brooklyn alternative pronounciation) you rarely see any more, potato and egg. And then they have variations on that with red pepper and optional ham on top. They make great, great meatballs and even their roast beef is better than anyone else's.

While looking at the chalkboard, I noticed they had a sandwich called the "Greaseball." On the way out I spoke to the woman (older than 50) who was the cashier who was no doubt related to the owners one way or another. I know a family runs both places.

I told her that if I ordered a "greaseball" in Brooklyn, it would probably end in a fight. "You know, give me a meatball parm and melt the muzzie real good and a yeah, give me a "greaseball." Boom. The woman laughed and agreed it would be a problem on 18th Avenue in Brooklyn but in Manhattan it is cute. But even 18th Avenue is losing its Italian flavor and becoming more Asian.

No Replies |Back to top

| Add a Reply

Sign in to comment.

Recent Activity

  • Announcement: Writers Needed for Morocco Guidebook
    by Emily_D Fodor's Editor | Posted on Apr 11, 14 at 05:51 PM
View all United States activity »
  1. 1 Hotel recommendation for San Francisco
  2. 2 Camping Summer of 2015 Yellowstone? Yosemite? GT?
  3. 3 rain in Kauai
  4. 4 Where to go in Maine?
  5. 5 Jersey City Parking
  6. 6 Hotel in Santa Barbara
  7. 7 Antelope Canyon. Tour form Page or just show up there and pick a guide ?
  8. 8 Autumn stay on Cape Cod
  9. 9 SF to DR? WTH!
  10. 10 Kennebunkport and....?
  11. 11 AirBnB is illegal in San Francisco,
  12. 12 NYC Itinerary Help
  13. 13 Christmas cruise in Hawaii
  14. 14 WISCONSIN
  15. 15 VRBO/Airbnb rental status in San Francisco
  16. 16 Washington DC Self Planned Walking Tour
  17. 17 Baggage on United and Delta Flights
  18. 18 Washington DC in May for 4 days
  19. 19 Trip Report Washington, D.C. trip report...
  20. 20 Someplace warm and beachfront for winter 2015
  21. 21 MICHIGAN - UPPER PENINSULA
  22. 22 West coast and East coast trip for 18 days
  23. 23 MACINAC ISLAND, MI TO CHICAGO, IL
  24. 24 Washington, DC to Boston
  25. 25 RIP Rizzoli, J&R Music, Pearl Paint
View next 25 » Back to the top