United States Forums

Post New Topic

Recent Activity

View all United States activity »
  1. 1 Advertising Sublets in NYC Now Illegal - Air BnB Has Pulled Listings
  2. 2 Las Vegas Vacation
  3. 3 Warmth in December without Zika??
  4. 4 LA! Active, FUN couple - area to stay/itenerary
  6. 6 Trip Report DC restaurant report
  7. 7 Eastern California Winter Roadtrip
  8. 8 Travel in Houston and surrounding area
  9. 9 Trip Report Trip Report: San Francisco, Monterey, Wine Country
  10. 10 The famous SF -> Seattle road trip
  11. 11 Washington DC Trip in December with Small Children
  12. 12 Trip Report Northern California Redwoods
  13. 13 2016/17 Ski Season Opens
  14. 14 Southwestern Virginia Ideas?
  15. 15 Smoky Mountains Honeymoon
  16. 16 East Tennesee to mohonk.
  17. 17 Neue Galerie
  18. 18 SF with school-age kids -- too much to choose!
  19. 19 Thoughts on our Palm Springs Plans
  20. 20 Polynesian Cultural Centre
  21. 21 Philadelphia - Safe?
  22. 22 Arizona in winter
  23. 23 SF-Yosemite-Monterey Peninsula
  24. 24 NYC bus tour suggestions
  25. 25 Arizona in late January
View next 25 » Back to the top

Maui v. the Big Island, which has better snorkeling?

Jump to last reply


Planning our first visit to HI in early September (myself, husband and daughter (early 20s). We will be spending 9 nights and splitting our stay between Oahu and either Maui or the Big Island. Looking forward to lots of sightseeing and activities on Oahu - Pearl Harbor, surf lessons, exploring chinatown, driving out to the north shore (and for DD, shopping and seeing any of the locations where LOST filmed).

For the second island, we know it will be more relaxing and we are trying to decide between Maui v. the Big Island. Deciding factor may come down to better snorkeling, as it is an activity we all enjoy. We're interested in both off shore experiences, where you can just wade in from the beach, as well as boat excursions (eg Molokini crater). I have 3 different guidebooks but am having a hard time determining which island would be better for this in early September. I humbly turn to fellow Fodorites for your opinions.

Thanks for any insights you can provide.

11 Replies |Back to top

Sign in to comment.