United States Forums

Post New Topic

Recent Activity

  • How do you plan your trips?
  • Please help us learn by participating in a brief survey.
View all United States activity »
  1. 1 What type of hire car for Nat Parks in UT, AZ
  2. 2 Maui Bed and Breakfast
  3. 3 Sonoma
  4. 4 Northwest Passage
  5. 5 Middle aged and overweight - can I hike
  6. 6 Fodor's Travel QA Test_20170428141326
  7. 7 ONLY 2 DAYS IN WILLIAMSBURG
  8. 8 Alaska cruise
  9. 9 Spur of the moment Chicago advice.
  10. 10 Family Colorado Road Trip
  11. 11 Fodor's Walt Disney World 2017 travel guide
  12. 12 Trip Report Kauai - wow, just WOW!!!
  13. 13 Colorado Forest Die Off - How Awful Is It? Should We Visit Elsewhere?
  14. 14 101 closure
  15. 15 North Rim, Page, Bryce & Zion Advice
  16. 16 Springfield, IL to Louisville, KY best route
  17. 17 Lowkey, waterfront, natural area for winter months--no high rises
  18. 18 Seattle and Vancouver/Victoria
  19. 19 Cruise to Alaska. Ports- Juneau, Sitka, Ketchikan, Victoria
  20. 20 fairfeld inn or Hampton inn
  21. 21 NE Itinerary - Thoughts?
  22. 22 Trip Report Trip Report 2012 : 11 wonderful days in Alaska
  23. 23 Gate1 8 Day Grand Canyon tour review/ Comments
  24. 24 New Orleans
  25. 25 Kentucky Derby Shuttle
View next 25 » Back to the top

JFK to New Haven--car or train?

Jump to last reply

Sorry, we're switching gears so new question:

Overall, is it better to A) rent a car at JFK and drive to New Haven (we'll be going to Hartford the next day), or, B) take a shuttle from JFK to Manhattan then take a train to New Haven?

We are two adults and one well-traveled 11 year old. We'll have a daypack and one rolling suitcase each. We've done the plane, train, bus, taxi thing a lot.

We'd planned to rent a car in New Haven anyway (only $100 for 3 days inc tax with Enterprise) to get to Hartford, but now I'm wondering why we don't just brave Manhattan with a rental car from JFK instead.

we are from LA but have never driven in Manhattan (though we've managed Paris and other chaotic traffic cities).

Thanks!

10 Replies |Back to top

Sign in to comment.

Advertisement