United States Forums

Start a new topic Change Forum
Advanced search

Hudson Valley - renting a car

Jump to last reply

Good morning

I need to get on the stick about prepping for our trip coming up soon... We will be in the Hudson Valley for 3 nights, starting and ending in Manhattan.

Would it be the easiest for us to take ourselves (with luggage in tow) via train to the end point in the Hudson Valley and pick up a rental there, or, should we get a car closer to Manhattan/in Manhattan?

Seems like the train makes more sense (pickup and dropoff three days later, then train back to Manhattan) but thought I'd ask.

Muchas Gracias

27 Replies |Back to top

| Add a Reply

Sign in to comment.

Recent Activity

  • Announcement:
  • Introducing MeganM
    by Emily_D Fodor's Editor | Posted on Apr 24, 15 at 03:23 PM
View all United States activity »
  1. 1 Purchase of Florida Condo
  2. 2 New York in May - Dinner at Bouley,
  3. 3 NC or SC Beach Escape
  4. 4 family road trip
  5. 5 Kid School Admission
  6. 6 Connecticut Highway 1. Should we do it?
  7. 7 Pacific Coast Highway from Los Angeles to San Francisco
  8. 8 Recommended Private Shuttle Service From JFK Airport to Long Island City
  9. 9 Broadway Banter revived, Spring 2015!
  10. 10 Lake Tahoe - May Vacation Advice
  11. 11 New York City-New Things?
  12. 12 Trip Report Kauai - wow, just WOW!!!
  13. 13 Alaska Trip Planning
  14. 14 which St. Louis neighborhood to base in, given these destinations?
  15. 15 Trip Report A Napa Valley Reprise: Mom turns the big 5-0!
  16. 16 final plans utah/arizona trip
  17. 17 Trip Report 2 Short Trips to NYC: Broadway, Opera, Tenements, Hotels, Cholesterol
  18. 18 SOS....Thunderstorms when we plan to visit NOLA
  19. 19 4 Days in Kauai what to see and do
  20. 20 scenic route from Estes Park to Salt Lake City
  21. 21 Traveling from Vegas to Grand Canyon and Southern Utah
  22. 22 Restaurant recomendations in the east 54th Street area, please.
  23. 23 Traffic from Wine Country to SFO on weekday
  24. 24 NYC hotel/July
  25. 25 Boston to see Sargent works
View next 25 » Back to the top