On Kauai, check out www.hanaleisurfboardhouse.com

It is in a terrific location on Hanalei Bay and the town of Hanalei is very laid back, with good restaurants. Lots to see on Kauai.

On The Big Island of Hawaii, there is the Hawaiian Volcanoes National Park to visit. It is also nice to stay in the town of Volcano for the difference in environment. There are lots of very nice B&B's there, some of which are rain forest types, some of which are classic old bungalow types. TBI isn't really a foodie destination. There is more in terms of foodie activity on Oahu, more ethnic cuisine stuff. You might want to check out www.chowhound.com to get ideas of what's available in Honolulu or thereabouts.

Love the look of the Hanalei Surf Board House! Thanks! Will look at that and the Koa Kea.

I would pick Hawaii that time of year. Only know of a winery/vineyards in Maui and the Big Island. Where are you coming from? Budget?

There used to be a stand-alone unit there called the Love Shack. I don't see it on the website, but you might consider asking if that is still available.

Dang - lost a post while trying to get this webpage.

Anyhow - good choices and I would suggest you might go to say Mallora/Majorca - since you will probably have more time now - and could later more easily get over to Hawaii - which I love, especially the North Shore of Kauai and the Big Island.

If it were me - and to satisfy some "foodie" lust - fly into Paris - and then after a few days - make your way down to the Med and take a ferry from say Barcelona as we did - or possibly from Nice or somewhere in France.

Here is one page and there are others: http://balearics.angloinfo.com/information/35/ferries.asp

BTW - there are plenty of places in Hawaii that are not mega resorts and fun to stay. Come back with more questions when you get a better idea of your semi-final choices.

BTW Dos: You could also "open jaw" into say Paris and fly back from Barcelona, saving having to retrace your route if you decided to see the "City of Light" first.

BTW Tres: You can also fly from Europe to Palm de Majorca, apparently not that much more expensive now than taking the ferry? http://www.lonelyplanet.com/thorntree/thread.jspa?threadID=2054917

I am the rare person here who has not been to Hawaii or Majorca but has been to Terciera (Azores). Our daughter was stationed there at Lajes with the USAF for over a year.
The drive around the island took nearly all day. Once you got away from the 2 main cities, there was no throng of tourists.
There are charter boats that can show you some of the rugged coastline which you can't see any other way.
It was interesting landing at Lajes with its runway shared by the Portugese AF and the commercial airport. There is a cow pasture next to the runway.
We did have to fly from Newark to Lisbon and then back to Lajes.

<but it seems like everything is built around mega family resorts>

Well your impressions is simply not true. I'm not sure where you are doing your research but the Hawaiian islands are incredibly diverse. You can find ALL kinds of independent accomodations that in no way resemble "mega family resorts". You can rent private homes, cottages, stay at small island-style hotels, get a condo or apartment, B&B, etc. in cities, towns, or out in the countryside or coastline. All the islands have a variety of options.

Thank you for the suggestions so far. We are coming from NYC and therefore, it would be a bit of a haul. But, it is our honeymoon and we have two weeks. I've tried to find hotels on the beach that are smaller, but am having trouble finding some that seem like it is a mix of island style and pampering. Our budge doesn't allow for a place like the Four Seasons Maui, but can probably spend up to about 400 a night (but of course would prefer cheaper and ideally around 250 a night). My fiance doesn't want to rent a house as he wants to feel like he is on vacation and not making the bed or washing dishes ( I personally don't care). If we go to Kauai, we are staying at the Koa Kea or the Hanalei Surfboard House (great suggestion and maybe we will do both). The Big Island or Maui is where we are getting stuck with where to stay near the beach (but knowing we will hike inland).
Tonsd, And thanks for the threads on Mallorca and the ferries!...Hawaii seems beautiful and I've never been, but the idea of tapas, wine, and the Mediterranean are also calling my name.
tomfuller...you didn't seem that enthusiastic about the Azores? Were they just ok?
Thanks again everyone! Very helpful!

For Kauai - so many great places on the North Shore at Hanelei and Princeville and beyond. We have a timeshare at the Cliffs Club in Princeville (bought during our Honeymoon in '86) but for really getting away - check out the Hanalei Colony Resort - which reportedly now has a good Luau and there is good snorkeling right in front. http://www.hcr.com/?utm_source=google&utm_medium=cpc&utm_term=hanaleicolonyresort&utm_campaign=rezstream&gclid=CPDUia2e1q8CFcIFRQodgSmYDQ

When we were there - yes, years ago - the very lively Charo had her restuarant there, and we met her at a party or two. Very funny - gucci gucci gal.

There also other nice homes/condos in the area - such as at Anini Beach. http://www.homeaway.com/vacation-rentals/hawaii/anini-beach/r5034

Took a wind surfing lesson there, and enjoyed a picnic on the grass - while watching Sly Stallone play polo there. Think he sold his lovely home years ago - as did Bette Midler and Kareem Abdul Jabaar.

I think I will enjoy the Island of Hawaii more than Terciera.
TAP lost my wife's checked bag. We had to travel to Angra de Hermosa to their office for reinbursement. We had a very good meal in Praia with the money they gave us. 3 days later we got the bag back minus the strap that held the luggage tag.
The population has dropped to less than 55000.
http://theazoresislands.blogspot.com/2007/12/terceira-island-of-contrasts-history.html
When driving in the countryside, be prepared to see goats in the road. The flowers growing on the stone fences are nice.

Here is my two cents:
Hawaii is our home . We have been to Barcelona and Majorca for short stays and loved both locales. Barcelona is a very vibrant and a "young" city. Endless shopping, eating, and museums.
Marjorca is much simpler and beautiful. The two might given you a nice variety since you have two whole weeks.
If you are looking to "beach" the entire stay Lanai is my idea of a honeymoon splurge.It is beautiful and tranquil. You could go to Maui or Kauai thereafter for a different pace.
Regardless have a lovely time.

I find Lanai nice for a day visit, but after that it gets boring. Yes, I said it. And this would not be the place to put a foodie.

Lanai has some good dining options, certainly enough for a week. It is a kickback type place - with great golf courses and good snorkeling, but it is the smallest/least inhabited of the islands. Molokai is the next smallest, and while I like Lanai - think Molokai would have more to offer, especially the great waterfall/hike at the east end.

But our two favorites are Kauai - especially the North Shore and the Big Island, although they all have something special.

Again, from a time viewpoint, when is the next time you think you will get two weeks off? If you haven't been to Paris and Barcelona - I would do that the first week and then get to Mallorca or Ibiza, etc for the 2nd week. There are usually package deals to Hawaii that I think would be easier/less expensive than flying over to Europe, that you could take advantage of in the future.

But since you are in NYC - it might be a wash?

Honestly as much as I love Hawaii, for a honeymoon and starting of in NYC, I'd head to Europe. Save Hawaii for another vacation in the future.

I would also consider the flight times. LONg way from NYC to hawaii and so much shorter to europe. I also love, love, love hawaii but from the east coast, I'd pick Europe especially after all the hustle and bustle of a wedding. hawaii is wonderfull but most places are a bit crowded unless you try Molokai and Lanai good luck in trying to figure it all out.....