United States Forums

Start a new topic Change Forum
Advanced search

Have concerns about Maui/Kauai. Are they valid?

Jump to last reply

We're planning a trip (no kids) for early September for 10 nights. We went to the Big Island last year (3 nights Hilo, 5 nights Hilton Waikoloa Village) and for this year are considering 3 nights Honolulu and 7 nights Hapuna Beach Prince on the Big Island (well, the Mauna Kea would be our dream resort, but the price is prohibitive).

However, we are also considering other itineraries, perhaps including Kauai or Maui instead.

What we liked about the Big Island:

1) Relatively quiet and uncrowded; and
2) Hapuna Beach was beautiful (also uncrowded).

Fears about Maui:

1) Crowds (particularly at the beaches);
2) Choice of big, poor service, mass market resorts (Kaanapali) or paying insane amounts for Wailea hotels (though the Fairmont has special renovation rates). To be clear, we do not like (nor could we afford) something like the Four Seasons or Grand Wailea. But we've read stories about the Kaanapali resorts that make us nervous. We don't want to be fighting for seats by the pool or waiting in long lines.

Fears about Kauai:

1) Restaurant options;
2) Rainy?;
3) Beaches comparable to Hapuna or Mauna Kea.

Given the time of year we'd be going (early September), any input on whether our concerns about Maui and Kauai are particularly valid/relevant?

We are looking to split up the trip between two islands at the most with a 6 night/4 night or 7 night/3 night split.

Thanks!

David

23 Replies |Back to top

| Add a Reply

Sign in to comment.

Recent Activity

  • Announcement:
  • Fodor's 100 Hotel Award Winners Announced
    by Emily_D Fodor's Editor | Posted on Sep 17, 14 at 01:05 PM
View all United States activity »
  1. 1 Portland, OR to Crater Lake to Portland- most scenic route
  2. 2 Long Weekend Travel - Where to?
  3. 3 Trip Report TripReport--10 Utah Circle
  4. 4 Lunch near 254 west 54th st.
  5. 5 Cabo cancelled, so where shall 14 of us go for childless long wknd??
  6. 6 Tucson area flooding
  7. 7 Trip Report Boston suggestions
  8. 8 lunch in Boulder CO TODAY!!
  9. 9 Need suggestions: 6-day Thanksgiving trip Seattle,Portland,Vancouver(maybe)
  10. 10 Palm Desert California recommendations for dining
  11. 11 Itinerary suggestions/advice for driving fr PAlto/Sequoia/GC/LV/Palo Alto
  12. 12 Fairbanks, denali, kenai peninsula
  13. 13 Restaurant recommendations for Ft. Lauderdale
  14. 14 December 2014 travel. Family w/young adults
  15. 15 Edison Hotel or Holiday Inn Express manhattan midtown w
  16. 16 Winter/Spring Trip Ideas from Ohio
  17. 17 Ben Landa
  18. 18 4 week family trip ideas
  19. 19 Need a Hampton Restaurant Suggestion
  20. 20 Looking For Warm Vacation Spot for December in US With 16 Months Old
  21. 21 Looking for Next Destination
  22. 22 Best Sonoma wineries you've never heard of
  23. 23 West Coast Road Trip
  24. 24 Glacier NP & Yellowstone NP 8 day trip Itinerary
  25. 25 Albuquerque to Vegas drive and sights
View next 25 » Back to the top