United States Forums

Start a new topic Change Forum
Advanced search

Drive or Take the Train; Day trip from Philadelphia to NYC

Jump to last reply

I piggybacked this question on another thread, and it sank with no answers. Please forgive me if it sounds familiar.

We'll be going into NYC from Philadelphia just for one day. At her request, we'll be taking a new Swarthmore graduate to a matinee of Wicked and out for dinner at the Oyster Bar in Grand Central Station. Amtrak tickets are currently $70 RT. With three of us, would it make sense to drive into Manhattan? We're thinking to arrive in NYC around 11 AM and leave ~ 9 PM.

I've taken the train from Boston to Phil in the past and it was a pleasant trip. With tolls, gas, parking for the day, and the hassle of driving, will we regret not paying $210 for train tickets? I'm also a bit concerned we may not be able to agree on a time and end up with even higher ticket prices.

Any suggestions?

18 Replies |Back to top

| Add a Reply

Sign in to comment.

Recent Activity

  • Announcement:
  • Fodor's Go List 2015 Has Been Announced
    by Emily_D Fodor's Editor | Posted on Dec 19, 14 at 05:08 PM
View all United States activity »
  1. 1 August 2015 Western Roadtrip Route? 30 days...Two 22-year-old Girls
  2. 2 Utah-Arizona National Parks intinary help needed
  3. 3 Last Minute NYE Trip to DC - Fancy Tea? Other special ideas...Wanted
  4. 4 Trip Report The East Coast adventure: December 2014
  5. 5 Please help identify location in Southern California
  6. 6 3 weeks in USA in February -- refined itinerary
  7. 7 WHY are rental cars in December in Florida so expensive?
  8. 8 After Chigago ? side trips- suggestions
  9. 9 Need help planning weekend trips: Georgia, Chicago, Tennessee, Alaska?!
  10. 10 Quick Austin weekend itinerary review
  11. 11 Denver Airport to Downtown Sheraton--Transportation Options?
  12. 12 Grand Tetons, Yellowstone and Banff in May or early Sept.?
  13. 13 Best Destination in USA
  14. 14 Rules of the Sidewalk
  15. 15 Road trip March from Atlanta
  16. 16 Nashville - Weekend Trip
  17. 17 Dinner stop between Boston and Bradley Airport in CT (Windsor)
  18. 18 NYT article on exploring Los Angeles without a car
  19. 19 x mas
  20. 20 Zion, Bryce, Page, GC South Rim, and Arches
  21. 21 US 101 closed N of Florence
  22. 22 FLORIDA CONDO--seeking general advice
  23. 23 Deep South roadtrip, 3 weeks, 2 more Brits needing your help!
  24. 24 Help with seeing Rocky Mountain National Park
  25. 25 Choosing best Seats Radio City
View next 25 » Back to the top