United States Forums

Start a new topic Change Forum
Advanced search

Down to three New York City hotels for December visit

Jump to last reply

After doing A LOT of looking, I'm down to three hotels for our pre-Christmas visit. We plan to arrive the Saturday before Christmas (working around a college student schedule) and stay three or four nights, depending on airfares. Our family of four visited NYC ten years ago in June and stayed at The Blakely Hotel. The Blakely (W. 55th) is still in the mix, along with two others - San Carlos Hotel (E. 50th) and The Refinery (W. 38th). As well as visiting places we missed last time and go to a show, we plan to do Christmasy things: window decorations, ice skating, and the Rockettes.

From the pictures, the decorating style of The Blakely is the same as our previous visit, the San Carlos Hotel seems to be a neutral style and The Refinery looks more contemporary. All three have similiar reviews, with The Refinery edging out the San Carlos Hotel and The Blakely. Depending on the room choice, refundable room rates for four nights at the San Carlos Hotel are either $1555 or $1843 (nonrefundable rates are $1244 or $1480). The Refinery rates are either $1501 or $1684. The Blakely rates are $2127.

Do you have any thoughts? It would be amazing if someone had experience with all three, but you never know. If it's a "wash", that's good to know, too. Whichever one we pick, we'll bring our snow boots! Thank you.

16 Replies |Back to top

| Add a Reply

Sign in to comment.

Recent Activity

  • Announcement:
  • Fodor's Go List 2015 Has Been Announced
    by Emily_D Fodor's Editor | Posted on Dec 19, 14 at 05:08 PM
View all United States activity »
  1. 1 From NY to Miami with 3 teenage kids
  2. 2 Transportation from Newark airport to Secaucus
  3. 3 3 weeks in USA in February -- refined itinerary
  4. 4 Rules of the Sidewalk
  5. 5 Wyndham timeshares--should we or shouldn't
  6. 6 After Chigago ? side trips- suggestions
  7. 7 Restaurant in NYC advice
  8. 8 USA New York City: First-time Visitors
  9. 9 5 Days in San Antonio and Austin Texas
  10. 10 Solo Female Traveller to New Orleans
  11. 11 Trip Report San Diego Girl's Trip in December
  12. 12 Avis Car rental Loss Damage Waiver LDW Fraud
  13. 13 Dad and daughter trip to Santa Fe
  14. 14 Tipping advice
  15. 15 Wilmington, NC to Raleigh - Anything interesting to see in between?
  16. 16 charleston during Christmas Week
  17. 17 Fort Myers Beach vs Naples Beach
  18. 18 Advanced Reservations for USS Arizona Memorial Available Again
  19. 19 New Hawaii countdown for 2014-15
  20. 20 Queens, NY - Do not go
  21. 21 Tuscon to Las Vegas Drive in December
  22. 22 Hawaii Rental Cars - Book early
  23. 23 Boston, NYC or Chicago for 3rd weekend in March?
  24. 24 Maui - Need a Vegan-Friendly Restaurant Recommendation
  25. 25 Denver Airport to Downtown Sheraton--Transportation Options?
View next 25 » Back to the top