Travel Tips & Trip Ideas Forums

Start a new topic Change Forum
Advanced search

THRIFTY vs DOLLAR rental car; why am I hesitating?

Jump to last reply

Have any of you had good, bad, or indifferent experiences with either Thrifty or Dollar rental cars? I've always done National, Avis, or Hertz, but I am shocked at how much lower the Thrifty & Dollar cars are vs the rest of the field.

For 4 days in Colorado this summer, (not including a Sat night or Sunday, so I can't get a weekend rate), I can get a Compact from either Thrifty or Dollar for approx $195, a weekly rate--including taxes and charges--not a discount; that's the regular rate. A far distant third is Hertz, with $358 for the same car and weekly rate--including a small AAA discount. (I couldn't find a way to enter a AAA discount for Thrifty or Dollar.)

My concerns are: Am I overlooking something here? Can there be THAT much difference in price? Are Dollar and Thrifty as reputable as the other services. Any clue as to why Hertz is almost twice as much and National, Avis, and even Budget are OVER twice as expensive?

Thank you. I'll be checking and hoping for replies.

Logan

14 Replies |Back to top

| Add a Reply

Sign in to comment.

Recent Activity

  • Announcement:
  • Fodor's Go List 2015 Has Been Announced
    by Emily_D Fodor's Editor | Posted on Dec 19, 14 at 05:08 PM
View all Travel Tips & Trip Ideas activity »
  1. 1 Holiday Wish List for Vacation Rental Owners
  2. 2 Travel Tote to attach to rolling bag
  3. 3 Help finding a lifestyle resort
  4. 4 how to add my photo to my passport renewal application?
  5. 5 Hawaii or Rio for solo single male travel
  6. 6 Travel SIMs
  7. 7 An Introduction to new member
  8. 8 Priceline.com "Best Price guaranteed"scam
  9. 9 Travelling in June
  10. 10 Travel with 13 yr old nephew - need help on where please!
  11. 11 Friends Seeking Advice
  12. 12 Barclaycard Arrival MC chip & pin useless in Italy
  13. 13 Anyone have suggestion for best tablet to use when traveling? under $300
  14. 14 25th wedding anniv travel
  15. 15 $950,000 travel insurance mistake
  16. 16 Best places to start...
  17. 17 Trip Report I TRAVEL THE WORLD ALONE
  18. 18 Need packing tips: 24 days in Japan
  19. 19 two months away and mold problems.
  20. 20 Need suggestions for solo trip (2-3 weeks, next May)
  21. 21 French gastronomy
  22. 22 Noise Cancelling Headphones
  23. 23 Travel Tote/Bag (women) for carrying on plane
  24. 24 Looking for a hat to wear in the rainforest
  25. 25 NEED URGENT DESTINATION ADVICE!
View next 25 » Back to the top