We would love advice on which one to visit in Oct or Nov. I hear food is very expensive in St Thomas but is it also in Aruba? Which has best snorkeling or scuba diving? I would love a nice beach but also hiking and seeing nice natural sights.
Thanks so much for advice.
This is for our 25th wedding anniversary!!
Aruba or St Thomas
Recent Activity
View all Travel Tips & Trip Ideas activity »
- 1
Goin' solo...nothing like it! (A trip report collection)
- 2 LADIES: FAVORITE UNDER SEAT PERSONAL BAG AND WHAT TO PACK IN IT?
- 3 Italy, Greece and turkey holiday
- 4 Scottevest jacket product quality issues
- 5 Sardinia, Italy
- 6 Vacation Destination
- 7
Packing list - 6 months with carry-on only
- 8 traveling with fifteen year old grandson
- 9
I TRAVEL THE WORLD ALONE
- 10 train tickets for italy
- 11 iPad use on long flights
- 12 Shoe Trouble
- 13 Good article on shoes for travel
- 14 Rose Bowl Parade
- 15 Single Senior Citizen travel
- 16
BEWARE of Grand Circle Travel SCAMS!!!
- 17 Buying SNCF tickets
- 18 5 week opportunity to travel - any tips where?
- 19 Changes in Travel Insurance: deductible
- 20 How to avoid delays at US border?
- 21 meditation - yoga - retreates.
- 22 Home Exchanges
- 23 Comparison of Budget Booking Sites
- 24 Where to go in August?
- 25 Organic Farming vacations - WWOOF USA



Then try St. Martin (the French side), or my favorite, St. Barths.
St. Thomas is such a tourist trap with all the cruise ships there every day.
St. Barths' harbor won't fit a cruise ship. Being in the shadow season, lodging should be very inexpensive, relatively speaking.
Welcome to Fodors hukapuk. This board is more for general travel discussions, not destination-specific questions. You will want to re-post over on the Caribbean forum where MANY more Fodorites will see/read it.
(See the 'Change Forum' pull down menu)