South America Forums

Post New Topic

Recent Activity

View all South America activity »
  1. 1 Time in Lima, then Guayaquil, Manta
  2. 2 Exciting Times in Colombia
  3. 3 Trip Report Trip Report - 2 Weeks in Peru, July 2016
  4. 4 Day Trip Ideas from Rio...
  5. 5 Best place to exchange USD for Peso
  6. 6 Galapagos - 11 full days
  7. 7 Mindo places with comfortable beds and flexible menus?
  8. 8 Trip Report Sixty days in Colombia
  9. 9 Video from Chile (Chiloé & Volcan Calbuco)
  10. 10 Colca Canyon Earthquake
  11. 11 Sketching Out a Rough Itinerary - First Trip to South America
  12. 12 2 Weeks in Colombia & the Galapagos Islands
  13. 13 Car rental El Calafate and drop off in Chile
  14. 14 Lima Foodie Resource(s)
  15. 15 Argentina - Day trips in Ushuaia
  16. 16 Iguazu Falls -- 2 nights -- do we have it right?
  17. 17 Booking sites - HELP! Don't want to be scammed
  18. 18 summer olympics in Rio
  19. 19 2 Weeks in Rio in Nov End
  20. 20 Trip ideas for 2 weeks in South America??
  21. 21 Trip Report Tahuayo Lodge, Amazon
  22. 22 Most Efficient Travel from Peru to Chile?
  23. 23 Buenos Aires AND Iguazu Falls?
  24. 24 Ecuador -Rental Car, Clothing and Cotopaxi
  25. 25 Itinerary Help Brazil 10 days
View next 25 » Back to the top

Isla Magdalena v. Seno Otway Penguins!

Jump to last reply

We are heading down to Puerto Natales and do not have time to stay in Punta Areans before kicking off our TdP hiking trip. We would like to rent a car in Natales and drive down to either Seno Otway or all the way down to Punta Arenas to meet up with the trip to Isla Magdalena.

I am wondering if anyone has insight on which would be better for us to do. I know that either way its going to make for a long day, but I can't come all this way and not go see the penguins! Has anyone done this in a round trip from Natales in a day? Does anyone have an opinion about which of the two is better? I thought Seno Otway would be closer to Natales but maybe the difference in distance isn't really worth it if Isla Magdalena is better.

Thanks for your help!

  • Report Abuse

    I might be too late for you...but I visited both places in early December of this year. From what you write, I would suggest Seno Otway, as it is a bit north of Punta Arenas and requires only a 45 minute ride (one way) from the main road to access. It's also wide open in terms of the timing of a visit. Isla de Magdalena requires 2 hours plus each way by boat (depending on the seas), and leaves only at 3:30pm three days a week. [Note that there is another, smaller boat to Isla de Magdalena, the "fast boat" that goes every day, but I personally would have little interest in being in a zodiac in the middle of the Strait of Magellan, especially after getting pitched around in 10' swells in the big boat.]

    The upside to Seno Otway is that you have it mostly to yourself and there is no time limit (Magdalena is a semi-structured one hour visit, and it can sometimes be a bit shorter if you are looking at rough weather). The obvious disadvantage to Seno Otway is that it is a much smaller colony and a much less dramatic landscape (the colony on Isla de Magdalena is more than ten times larger, and the penguins are literally everywhere).

    Both are extremely worthwhile trips, and they are different enough to do both if you have time...but driving five hours R/T and sailing for five hours R/T at a fixed time would be my second choice.

1 Reply |Back to top

Sign in to comment.

Advertisement