medstudent

My wife and I are planning a trip for early July '07. We're not sure where we want to go yet, but it absolutely has to have nice beaches and access to forrest like scenery - waterfalls, chirping birds, howling monkeys =) etc. Our list of potentials:
1) Belize
2) Mexican Riveria
3) Dominica
What do you guys think? I've been to Dominica once (via Windjammer cruise) and absolutely loved it. But it's a pain - though not impossible - to get back to again. And given we're both poor grad students, we're definitely on a budget. Any help/advice would be much appreciated!

medstudent

Oh - forgot to include - this will be a 6night trip

Earthtraveler

Why isn't Costa Rica on your list?
That's my suggestion.

rickandpat

I've been to all 3 places you've listed -in the winter, not sure how the weather is in July -(and LOVED Belize and Dominica), plus Costa Rica. If you want jungle, waterfalls, wildlife and beaches, CR is the only one that fits the bill. And there are plenty of inexpensive but decent places to stay and eat there too.

Earthtraveler

Here is the link to my Costa Rica albums with some great beaches, forests, monkeys, and birds waiting for you to discover. There are some awesome waterfalls in CR also. I've seen a few but the best were before I went digital.

http://rvincent3.photosite.com

shillmac

rickandpat, I know it's the wrong board, but what did you think of Dominica? We've thought about going there in combination with a visit to our daughter in Puerto Rico.

medstudent

Thanks so much for the responses! What do you guys think of the mayan riviera? I'm sure the beaches will be nice. How are the various eco parks located nearby? (xcaret, tres rios, etc). Any comparison at all to CR? When we're not relaxing on the beach/eating good food, we're interested in water/wildlife activities. Travelling to mexico as opposed to CR will be very inexpensive for us (due to miles, 45,000pts for mexico, 75,000 needed for central america) so I want to make sure CR is worth the extra $$.

Earthtraveler

The Mex. caribe forest is mellower and I don't remember many animals except sea birds and of course great snorkling. I spent a month camping near Tulum back in the 70"s. The topography is flatter than CR. Nice place if you've never been. Chiapas? near Palenque has some nice rainforest, howler monkeys, and Misola falls near there where I almost died. DON'T swim under waterfalls. They tend to hold you under the water!

JeanH

I consider the Mayan Riviera a beach vacation and Costa Rica an adventure vacation. Not that there aren't beaches in Costa Rica or adventure in Mexico. If you're looking for stunning scenery head to Costa Rica.

Or compromise and head to Belize. Fly to Cancun and take the bus to the border. The scenery isn't as good as Costa Rica, but there are waterfalls, monkeys and ruins. The beaches aren't as nice as in Mexico, but the sand is white and the snorkeling is wonderful.

Earthtraveler

Shillmac,
We have also been to Dominica. Seems like in another life as it was so long ago. There was a nice accomodtion called Pappilon near an awesome waterfall, Trafalgar, that had some hotsprings in the upper parts that I could climb to. The beaches didn't impress me. Emerald Falls was nice. Hiked to the boiling lake and it was ok. The tours we so expensive then for us. I was more impressed with our time in Saint Lucia staying in what is now called Ladera? then Dasheen between the Pitons. The beach down below was not great except the Piton view but when the local boys came to visit and we shared some of our treats and then they went and picked a breadfruit and cooked it on the beach for us it made our day. I think the company has trucked in beach sand and built up that area now.

rickandpat

medstudent: I started dating my husband while he was in med. school (married right after), and he went through 8 long years of training (he's a cardiologist)before he started making any money to speak of - while we were paying back medical school loans . . . So I know about budgets! If Mexico is less expensive, maybe that's the best choice for this trip. But if you can swing the extra points, I would seriously consider doing so. I admit I have not gone far off the coast south of Playa del Carmen, though I've read about the eco-parks like Xcaret. They sound crowded and built for tourists with even some enclosed spaces for wildlife. The MR is pretty built up from what I saw between Cancun and the Playa del Carmen area, I never ran across any monkeys or toucans or other pretty birds. CR wildlife is everywhere,along the road as you drive even. The parks are large with trails through the jungle and along the coast, and natural. Waterfalls are found in mountainous terrain like CR, while the Mexican coast is flat. However, on the MR the water color is Caribbean blue, verses the not-quite-as gorgeous Pacific coast of CR (though the beaches are great and we love swimming there).

I guess it comes down to how much you want wildlife, amazing jungle, and waterfalls. Good luck making a decision! Pat

rickandpat

Shillmac: I really loved Dominica, and will go back since 4 nights was not enough for me. It is very mountainous and green, the roads were good but windy. Not many tourists since it's hard to get to, don't recall great meals (though that is never a priority for me), and poverty is pretty obvious. But the hiking and waterfalls! The snorkeling at Scotts Head and Champagne Reef (the latter not for the sea creatures, but the warm bubbles)! We went in early Feb., I'd probably try for a time when it would be a bit drier, especially if we were doing Boiling Lake again (a tough,tough slog). Though with all those sprinkles we saw a ton of rainbows. Pat

medstudent

Thanks so much everyone for their time. If I can gather the cash together, I think CR is the way to go...We shall see. Thanks again!

shillmac

earthtraveler and pat--thanks so much! St. Lucia, I agree, sounds like a good destination as well. Met a couple in CR last year who travel to Dominica every year and love it there. I hadn't even heard of it until last year when I read a review on the correct pronunciation, DominEEca!

Katie_Valk

Hidden Valley Inn in Belize has at least 7 private watefalls on its 7200 acre property, some of which you can rent for your own private use for about $125.00 per day with lunch and sprakling wine. Cool, huh?

etk401

We recently returned from the Riviera Maya. I was not impressed with excaret. Way too crowded, touristy, reminded me of a theme park. We are booked for CR in March and we are so excited. As far as which place, I have always said as long as I get to travel I try to adjust my expectations depending on destination and budget. Have fun where ever you go.

Earthtraveler

Correction- The lodge near Trafalgar Falls on Dominica is called Papillote. Googling Dominica brought back memories and I see it looks like a mini Costa Rica and a fine desination with grand vistas and beautiful rainforest.

jasmine3

my suggestion would be Costa Rica.
it has been one of our favorite places to vist.

5alive

I just read about a waterfall in Peru that turns out to be the third tallest in the world. The Gocta falls, 2500 feet.

It was known to the locals but just recently "discovered" and measured. A great article from the Washington Post, both the full citation and the same as tiny URL. There are also some great ruins to see. I'm envious of the people who will see this beauty before the commercialization.

http://tinyurl.com/uxy8p
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn...101300473.html

gwenivere

Earthtraveler: Could you answer some questions about Costa Rica?
1. How are the beaches compared to the Caribbean?
2. Is the water the same color as in the Caribbean?
3. Good snorkeling (clear waters?)
4. How are the hotels and the food?
5. Any suggestions on how to plan (where to go for our 10 days?)an iterary? We are planning to go for 10 days on our vacation.
6. Where are the best places to stay and restaurants?
7. Would you book this CR vacation through a travel agency/tour company or do it yourself?
8. What kind of shopping is available, if any?
Many thanks for your help!