Mexico & Central America Forums

Start a new topic Change Forum
Advanced search

Playa del Carmen or Isla Mujeres -- or somewhere else?

Jump to last reply

Hi all --

Okay, first off, I know I STILL haven't completed my trip report for our Costa Rica trip at the end of May. I've been a bad forum member! I'm sorry, and I will *try* to finish it eventually, but I can't make any promises...

So, for our next trip -- probably next March -- we're thinking we want an easy beachy vacation, with turquoise water, white sand, etc. The whole bit. To be honest, we've yet to do this kind of trip really, and I think we're deserving. I'm starting grad school in the fall, in addition to working f/t, so I'm sure by next March I will just want to go somewhere and chill out.

Now, neither one of us are total beach bums. It's really more about the water for us, playing and floating around. We tend to like to go to the beach for a few hours in the morning and then that's basically it for the beach for the rest of the day. But, if we were staying ON the beach, I'm thinking we might make more use of it? Maybe go back in the afternoon.

I'm looking strongly at Playa del Carmen and Isla Mujeres. I just can't decide, and each day I flip from one to the other. I know there are at least three other threads on here weighing the differences between Playa and IM, but I thought I'd try to get some more recent responses.

What I like about both of them are: 1. they are no more than an hour from the Cancun airport, give or take; 2. they both have seemingly beautiful water to play in; and 3. they both allow you to stay ON the beach yet be close enough to walk to a town with restaurants, wondering, etc.

I'm probably leaning more toward Playa simply because it seems a bit easier to get to, and I'm liking the hotel choices better (I think I've narrowed it down to Playa Maya, Mahekal, or Mimi del Mar -- among a couple of other options).

Isla is appealing because it's obviously less built up and busy -- and Playa Norte seems to win the battle of the beaches hands down. I'm just having a more difficult time finding a hotel that is clicking for us. I think we'd want to be on Playa Norte proper.

Anyway, if anyone has any recent experiences with either, I'd love to hear.

I've also looked at Puerto Morelos and Akumal, but I don't think either is clicking with me. Tulum looks nice, but we couldn't stay on the beach and walk to town, I don't think.

Thanks!

29 Replies |Back to top

| Add a Reply

Sign in to comment.

Recent Activity

  • Announcement: Writers Needed for Morocco Guidebook
    by Emily_D Fodor's Editor | Posted on Apr 11, 14 at 05:51 PM
View all Mexico & Central America activity »
  1. 1 Apartment Finders
  2. 2 Trip Report 5 Weeks in Chocolate Paradise
  3. 3 Driving from Florida to Belize
  4. 4 Looking for inexpensive villas/bungalows with a private/secluded beach.
  5. 5 Nicaragua trip on 5/22...Need help, pls
  6. 6 Costa Rica for a lone female?
  7. 7 Playa del Carmen - El Faro or Corto Maltes?
  8. 8 Puerto Vallarta for honeymoon... Ideas??
  9. 9 Guanajuato or San Cristobal de las Casas Mexico
  10. 10 Costa Rica - Dominical/Uvita in September with 2 yr old
  11. 11 Trip Report Spring in Oaxaca - a perfect getaway for our 15th wedding anniversary!
  12. 12 1 month itinerary US/Mexico
  13. 13 August weather in Cabo San Lucas?
  14. 14 Trip Report Photos from Panama (Chiriqui, Canal Zone) February 2014
  15. 15 Meditation and/or yoga retreat
  16. 16 NY Times article about Osa Peninsula
  17. 17 Suggestions for a Unique, Non-Touristy quick trip to the CANCUN area??
  18. 18 Petit Laffite hotel, Playa del Carmen
  19. 19 Advice for lazy *budget* beach vacation with 1 year old
  20. 20 Costa Rica - Family of 6 - July
  21. 21 Looking for Belize itinerary planning suggestions
  22. 22 Trip Report Family Vacation, Caribbean Costa Rica and Panama
  23. 23 Trip Report Hopefulist in Belize, 2014
  24. 24 International connectons through San Pedro Sula or Panama City
  25. 25 Looking for a resort similar to excellence playa Mujeres
View next 25 » Back to the top