Mexico & Central America Forums

Post New Topic

Recent Activity

View all Mexico & Central America activity »
  1. 1 Best time of year for Mexico City/Puebla?
  2. 2 Mexico City over Christmas
  3. 3 Need Help with Costa Rica
  4. 4 info needed on NW Mexico trip
  5. 5 Help! Should I go to Central America during the rainy season?
  6. 6 Tulum Beachfront Lodging with Tweens
  7. 7 Cozumel airport transfers
  8. 8 Best plan - suggestions
  9. 9 Playa Del Carmen restaurant
  10. 10 Vacation choices
  11. 11 Puerto Vallarta
  12. 12 nicaragua-Rancho Santana
  13. 13 Cabo, Playa, or PV?
  14. 14 PV Questions about art, food, cooking classes!
  15. 15 A First TripTo Puerta Vallerta
  16. 16 Transportation between Granada, Nicaragua and Ometepe, Nicaragua
  17. 17 Trip Report Old Town Puerto Vallarta May 2017
  18. 18 Isla Holbox - where did you stay?
  19. 19 Olmec Colossal Heads
  20. 20 Trip Report Tour Guide - Mexico City
  21. 21 Trip Report Tulum & Coba - Travel Report
  22. 22 1/2 day excursions
  23. 23 Thanksgiving/Riviera Maya area/All Inclusive
  24. 24 Going with the flow - 16 days in Costa Rica
  25. 25 top 8 cenotes to visit
View next 25 » Back to the top

Costa Rica Guide Book

Jump to last reply

We just returned from a fabulous 6 night stay in Costa Rica, toting our Fodor's Costa Rica 2011 Guidebook the whole way. For the most part, it was a valuable tool, but in a few areas it left me unfulfilled.

How do you decide what hotels and restaurants to include? We stayed at the JW Marriott in Guanacaste which is a gorgeous hotel completed in 2008, but is not mentioned in your guidebook at all except in a very vague statement in the Playa Avellanas paragraph. If I had not read the book from cover to cover, I never would have spotted it! Surely you must know that lots of people stay there and would like to refer to it in your book? And if you just have a bias against large resorts, then you would have given the Four Seasons the same treatment, but you did not. I am baffled. For anyone who is interested, the JW is a very nice resort which provided a lovely experience for a first time visitor to Costa Rica. I was looking for a hotel that would be a good fit for my family, including my 15 year old son who likes to surf and skim board. The JW is right in the midst of several beaches that are good for both of those activities.

We spent a couple of days in Tamarindo as well, and the hotels and restaurants that you included in that section were also incredibly sparse, and missing some highlights.

Overall, the guidebook was helpful, but I think you could do a more thorough job.

2 Replies |Back to top

Sign in to comment.

Advertisement