Europe Forums

Start a new topic Change Forum
Advanced search

Second guessing Italy over Christmas trip

Jump to last reply

My husband and I (early 30s) have never been to Europe mostly due to work schedules which prevent us from taking more than a week or so off at a time. The Christmas holiday lines up well this year so we are booked for a roundtrip flight from Southern U.S. to Florence, Italy, December 21 to 30.

That means we have 8 nights. We are currently scheduled to spend the first 5 nights with rental car near Siena at Castello di Casole which recently opened, and last 3 nights at Four Seasons in Florence. For countryside portion of the trip we plan on doing day trips to Siena, San G., Volterra, 2 Chianti Classico wineries, and 1 Brunello winery.

The inspiration for the trip was a 2010 NY Times article, "Tuscany in Winter," which made it sound fantastic with few crowds.

Now, I'm getting worried about a few things which are causing me to second guess the destination choice:

(1) should we have picked somewhere easier for first trip to Europe like maybe Paris?
(2) have we allotted too much time in countryside versus Florence?
(3) should we try to do a day trip to Rome?

I usually go through buyers' remorse after I book a trip but it's been particularly strong this time with all of the awesome recent Paris TRs here.

As to the countryside versus Florence allocation issue, we tend to prefer the countryside versus cities but I worry that the earlier darkness in the winter may make it hard to be in the countryside though it will be at a luxury resort with many amenities.

The Rome day trip idea is 80% a bad idea, checklist type of traveler thing which we are not. But, it seems very easy to get there. I was thinking if we did Rome we would add a day to Florence and subtract from countryside.

Would it be insane to change the schedule and do the first 3 nights in Rome (immediately take train from FLR to ROM) then come back and base ourselves at the FS Florence for 5 nights and do a few day trips into countryside from there?

Florence seems more interesting and relaxing to me personally than Rome which is why we booked it. We like great food, wine, scenery, and relaxation. We enjoy art and history but are more interested in the experience so don't want a frantic, harried type of trip.

Thanks very much in advance for everyone's wise input.

23 Replies |Back to top

| Add a Reply

Sign in to comment.

Recent Activity

  • Announcements:
  • Writers Needed for Mexico
    by Emily_D Fodor's Editor | Posted on Jul 24, 14 at 12:19 PM
  • Writers Needed for Georgia Coast
    by Emily_D Fodor's Editor | Posted on Jul 18, 14 at 03:12 PM
  • Writers Needed for Rwanda and Uganda
    by Emily_D Fodor's Editor | Posted on Jul 18, 14 at 03:12 PM
View all Europe activity »
  1. 1 Keeping it el cheapo in Copenhagen Paris and Barcelona!
  2. 2 If you had a week in Switzerland...
  3. 3 St. Paul's Cathedral bells
  4. 4 Italy things to do?
  5. 5 Trip Report Sirop and Sandwiches, Normandy, Loire and Paris with our grandsons
  6. 6 5 days in Florence - how would you do it?
  7. 7 Getting cash in Spain
  8. 8 Copenhagen, Bergen, Stockholm, Estonia and Helsinki Getting Around
  9. 9 How to do St. Petersburg in 24 or 48 hours with no visa?
  10. 10 Trip Report First trip we lost a car, this trip we lose a lady >)
  11. 11 Are taxis easily obtained at the train station in Florence?
  12. 12 Mozart - Salzburg or Vienna?
  13. 13 Trip Report I Go to Pieces — An Italy Trip Report
  14. 14 Help w/ rental car arrangements-Pickup in Lisbon, Portugal-Drop in Seville?
  15. 15 Rethymnon vs. Chania in early October?
  16. 16 A town in France for a month
  17. 17 Home base stay in Italy for vacation
  18. 18 Posting from Siena-ATM emergency! Help needed!
  19. 19 Saint Malo or Dinan?
  20. 20 Spend the day in Geneva or go straight to Chamonix?
  21. 21 Tentative itinerary for Andalucia for April/May 2015
  22. 22 Trip Report Thanks to Fodorites for help planning Paris/London trip
  23. 23 Trip Report Stay away from EF Tours
  24. 24 Base for 6 nights between Fussen and Garmisch Partenkirchen?
  25. 25 How to split nine days on Crete?
View next 25 » Back to the top