Isle of Skye or Mull and Iona

I am interested in this answer....

No chance you could do both? Mull is indeed lovely—as is Skye but not sure what 'nothing to do' means? What do you WANT to do?

There is nothing to 'do' anywhere -- if you mean nightlife. But I can't imagine what they meant or told your friend. Skye and Mull are different but they are both totally amazing places.

How many days did you plan on staying on either island??

I have only been to Skye once and then only for 2 nights. I was traveling with my granddaughter and our main purpose was to look at a college for her. We did have some time to explore the area but only in the vicinity of where we stayed. I was sorry I was not able to spend more time. We stayed at Skye Morar Bed and Breakfast Ardvasar, Sleat Isle of Skye, IV 45 BRU
Telephone 01471844378 or Mobile 07775 668223 011 444. There is a ferry 1 mile down the road to the mainland. We arrived at Portree by Ferry from Isle of Lewis and had about 3 hours to tour around Portree which is a charming town. The B and B was also very nice overlooking the water with a large terrace. The owners were very hospitable.

As far as nothing to do, if you like hiking you will find plenty to do. There are also wildlife tours by boat. I found more than one appealing and was disappointed that I did not have the time to go on one. There is not a lot of night life and where we stayed there was one restaurant only.
SKYE is incredibly beautiful. It is somewhat isolated but if you like nature and the outdoors you can find plenty to do in terms of hiking and exploring the outdoors. If you want to go on any wildlife tours I think they leave from Portree so you may want to stay in Portree because of the convenience. The other couples that were staying in the B and B were all there for about 4-5 days and were busy hiking the area. I imagine it takes time to explore the island if you are using public transportation. From what I recall there is a bus that travels about the island. Too bad that you do not have time for both islands.

http://www.skye.co.uk/
Here is the website for skye.

I haven't been to Skye, but Iona was a most amazing experience. I travelled with a friend who was a member of the catholic faith, and she was able to explain a lot of the symbolism to me.

Even without that benefit, just to see what those pioneering monks achieved in that climate was quite an education.

If you do plan to visit Iona, be sure to get the ferry across as early in the morning as possible. We made the mistake of reaching Oban mid-morning, so by the time we connected with ferries and did the drive, we had a bare minimum of time on the island, before we had to make our way back again. Di

I'm also wondering what "nothing to do" means. We spent two weeks on Skye two years ago and it was absolutely wonderful. But we were traveling with children and not looking to go out at night. We did a lot of walking and also took a boat trip from Elgol (there are several options for seeing nearby islands that way). Stark, in places, yes. Barren, well, yes, in the way islands can be. But it is spectacularly beautiful. As for things to do other than appreciate natural beauty, Portree is a nice town to visit and wander around in; Dunvegan Castle; Armadale Castle ruins; and the Talisker distillery spring to mind.

Mull and Iona are on my bucket list (I would love to spend a week with the Iona Community someday) and there's no reason NOT to see them - but don't skip Skye for the wrong reasons!

I get bored with the Skye questions on here; but the truth is, it's spectacular; probably the most spectacular bit of Scotland. The Black Cuillins ridge is the best climbing in the country, but there are lost of places to walk (hike in American parlance)without tempting Providence. One of the best 5 restaurants in the UK is here; and one of the nicest cafes (The Three Chimneys and Cafe Arriba); super wildlife as mentioned above- seals, dolphins, whales, eagles, White Tailed Eagles, otters, deer, piles of other bird species; a great castle with a Fairy Flag- srsly- the whole Flora McDonald/Bonnie Prince Charlie schtick, beaches, waterfalls, fossil hunting, boat trips, a great distillery, a great brewery....

To my knowledge, no night clubs but they do a mean ceilidh.

Mull OTOH has most of the above but without the spectacular (I know at least one person here disagrees with me on this, but if I never spent another week on Mull....). The only superiority- OK 2 superiorities- Mull has is Tobermory, which, to my mind is hugely nicer than Portree. The second one is the cheese. Isle of Mull Cheddar is to die for.

Iona is, on the third hand, special- and you can't get to it from Skye without your own helicopter (or boat). Pretty, spiritual and quiet- when the trippers aren't there. The best advice for Iona is to stay overnight. It's lovely when the ferries have stopped running. It's also a hop skip and a jump to Fingal's cave on Staffa, from Iona. Or Mull.

There; I hope that made it easier.

And yes, the airport is to the north west of Edinburgh. Mild advice- if you're flying in from the States, don't drive too far just after you've landed. You'll be slightly disorientated and you'll be on the "wrong" side of the road.

Thank you for your replies. I don't know what the person meant who told my friend that "there's nothing do do on Skye". My friend and I are definitly not interested in nightlife. I've read about a museum on Skye that sounds extremely interesting, and the wildlife and scenery sound wonderful.

Before now, I've never heard or read one unflattering thing about Skye. Part of the reason for this post is so I could show my friend the replies and convince her we need to spend some time there.

LaraS