Europe Forums

Start a new topic Change Forum
Advanced search

Trip Report Edinburgh Restaurants

Jump to last reply

Again, as promised a separate thread that will be easily searchable. ALL of these are in the New Town and w/one exception were less than .1 miles from our amazingly located B&B which was called 53 Frederick Street.
-------------------------------------------------------------------
Cafe Rouge 43 Frederick Street

This is a quite casual restaurant that offered surprisingly high quality food for very reasonable prices. I had a main dish salad which had delicious, fresh greens, other veggies and grilled chicken. DH had lamb which he said was delicious! One bad thing is that everywhere we went in Edinburgh, bread that *looked* like baguette had a soft, spongy rather unpleasant texture......not sure if it is a Scotland thing and whole wheat or "granary" bread was hard to find, but that was our ONLY complaint about food there. This rstrnt is a great place to go when you just want a simple place with inexpensive, good food and a low-key but very pleasant ambience. We spent >$60 for dinner for 2 w/wine and dessert.
----------------------------------------------
Cafe St. Honore 34 Norhthwest Thistle Street Lane

Tucked in a corner off of a tiny street, this was a little gem of what looked inside like a charming French bistro w/mirrors on the walls, dark paneling and lovely furniture. (It is going to seem like we only ate at "French" restaurants in Edinburgh but they were all interpreted by Scottish chefs and so were not strictly French. I just had the special menu of the day which was not memorable, but DH had "Borders Roe Deer" which he said was magnificent. This is what I mean by it not being strictly French, as the deer is Scottish. The place is not cheap, but the prices are fair for the quality. I think we spent ~$100 for dinner for 2 including a glass of wine each and 2 desserts.

--------------------------------------------------------
Brown's Restaurant 131 George Street

A large old building on a pleasant main street, that has been rehabbed inside to be very hip in its feel. All of the very high walls and ceilings and intricate moldings are painted a restful warm beige/navaho white, with ceiling fans up in the 25 feet (or higher ceilings.) The large room is divided into alcoves and balconies and the feel is one of hustle and bustle that is lively w/o being too loud. We were, no doubt, the oldest people there, (it was a Saturday night) and it was so great to see the young people of Edinburgh out enjoying themselves. The place could have been NYC, Chicago or LA--but in the good way-- and I was struck by how similarly dressed the young women were to the young women I see out at night in LA. The menu was creative and modern. Maybe a tad pricey for what you got, but not awful. It was a nice break from the other tiny places where we ate, and it was good to see an example of a modern re-purposing of a very old building. ~$100 or a tad more for 2.
--------------------------------------
La P'tite Folie 61 Frederick Street (They have another larger spot on Randolph Place, this one is more charming, IMO)

We ate here on a Friday night, but could have saved 30% or more by eating on Sun-Thur when they offer unbelievable specials on the same menu. Go then if you go! Really delicious, beautifully presented plates from what a friend of mine used to call the "tall food" style, where the entrees are served stacked, so to speak. My dish was bream (a fish I had never eaten which is white and mild, sort of like sole in its taste and appearance, which came topped in a cream sauce and fennel over green beans and delicately prepared potatoes. I cannot remember what DH had but will add it later. We shared an apricot frangipane for dessert and it was delicious! ~$125 but see note above to save!
--------------------------------
Cafe Marlayne Thistle Street, almost at the corner of Frederick Street)

This place is TINY. Reservations a must! Menu is handwritten and seems to change daily. Very good food, presented beautifully and again, altho French, not like eating in France. All of the "French" food we ate was definitely Scottish. Our selections were determined as much by convenience as anything, but our hotel just luckily happened to be in the middle of a restaurant mecca of Edinburgh.

BTW, both Browns and Cafe Marlayne were recommended to us by and Edinburgh resident. The others we just happened upon, altho DH did read their TripAdvisor ratings.

6 Replies |Back to top

| Add a Reply

Sign in to comment.

Recent Activity

  • Announcement:
  • Fodor's Go List 2015 Has Been Announced
    by Emily_D Fodor's Editor | Posted on Dec 19, 14 at 05:08 PM
View all Europe activity »
  1. 1 Driving an RV in Switzerland
  2. 2 Family vacay for 6 weeks with 2 Toddlers
  3. 3 Southern Spain
  4. 4 They Just Don't Read or Listen about DCC Scam
  5. 5 Taxi or Tube from LHR to Gloucester Road Tube?
  6. 6 29 day Itinerary for southern and eastern France
  7. 7 Paris-Loire-Avignon-Barcelona itinerary (help)
  8. 8 Minimalist wardrobe for Europe
  9. 9 Transportation from Athens Airport to Syntagma
  10. 10 Greece or Portugal for 3-4 week fall sojourn?
  11. 11 Siena - Pienza - Montepulciano
  12. 12 GuideAdvisor, beware!!
  13. 13 Treis-Karden 4 days and Trier 2 days?
  14. 14 Best Location for Car Pickup in Naples
  15. 15 All Set To Go!!
  16. 16 Trip Report Finally in Italy for the holidays - installment report
  17. 17 Andalucia - very early trip thinking - reactions?
  18. 18 Which european city?
  19. 19 Christmas in Paris and Strasbourg in 2015
  20. 20 Skippered Charter Greece Islands
  21. 21 Scotland November 2015
  22. 22 Swiss mountain scenery in late April
  23. 23 Bus Service Between Spoleto and Norcia
  24. 24 Earthquakes in Tuscany
  25. 25 Italy - Driving from Frankfurt to Florence (June 2012)
View next 25 » Back to the top