Europe Forums

Post New Topic

Recent Activity

  • How do you plan your trips?
  • Please help us learn by participating in a brief survey.
View all Europe activity »
  1. 1 Summer 2016: Little details I worried about – and need not have
  2. 2 Help required with Itinerary
  3. 3 San Francisco retirees would like to move to Paris for a year- crazy idea?
  4. 4 Como Bus to Bellagio
  5. 5 Are there any Paris walking guides I should add to my collection?
  6. 6 Trip Report "Paris? Again?" And an odd pickpocketing
  7. 7 Itinerary review from a overplanner
  8. 8 Campervan in Croatia
  9. 9 Greek Islands (small)
  10. 10 How early in the spring to visit London & England?
  11. 11 Cell Phone Question
  12. 12 Which is the cheapest country (and gorgeous) in Europe?
  13. 13 Advice for 5 Weeks in the Nordic Countries
  14. 14 K-Day
  15. 15 UK Visa Help
  16. 16 Skye to Edinburgh
  17. 17 Provence best farmstays!!??
  18. 18 Trip Report Trip report (long): Greek Macedonia, some insights into London's airports and the discovery of perhaps the worst airline in the developed world.
  19. 19 4 Days In Northern Italy advice
  20. 20 Chime in on Portugal Itineraryy
  21. 21 Spain in December
  22. 22 advance tickets?
  23. 23 Where to stay in September in the Swiss Alps
  24. 24 Where to go...one month w/a one year old
  25. 25 Marseille vs. Genoa
View next 25 » Back to the top

Buskers and beggars .. donate? if yes, how much?

Jump to last reply

Hi,

I just returned from a vacation to York and Edinburgh (some trip notes to come soon).

I remember seeing buskers on my last trip in 2010 to Edinburgh. I don't remember seeing people straight begging (sitting on sidewalk with cardboard sign). I saw one in York and 4-5 in Edinburgh.

Most of the Edinburgh folk who were straight begging also had dogs with them. One dog held a cap in his teeth. The others just slept.

I was really uncomfortable with the dog holding the cap. Yes, it attracted me to want to donate. I did not like how thin the dog was (complete skin-and-bones, no, but definitely on very thin side). I ended up walking on, not sure what to do, and uncomfortable with both the moving on and maybe putting in coin. If I had put in some coins, I really wondered if more food would be given the dog.

If someone is singing/playing instrument .. do you donate? how do you decide the yes/no? and if yes, then how much?

People sitting on the sidewalk with signs begging for funds .. do you donate? how do you decide the yes/no? and if yes, then how much?

Thanks.

26 Replies |Back to top

Sign in to comment.

Advertisement