Appalllingly Ill-Informed Fodors Article on the Dordogne
#1
Original Poster
Join Date: Jan 2003
Posts: 49,560
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Appalllingly Ill-Informed Fodors Article on the Dordogne
http://www.fodors.com/news/5-great-r...ogne-6883.html
My head is spinning reading this. It's hard to imagine how anyone could get so many facts wrong in so few words. Market days incorrect, place names misspelled, incorrect info about getting tickets to Lascaux, totally false info about the young man who discovered Lascaux, complete confusion between the Dordogne and Vézère rivers...I could go on and on, but it's shameful that they would pay someone to "write" something like this and makes you wonder if ANY of the travel info they put out, on the website or in their guidebooks, has any value whatsoever.
My head is spinning reading this. It's hard to imagine how anyone could get so many facts wrong in so few words. Market days incorrect, place names misspelled, incorrect info about getting tickets to Lascaux, totally false info about the young man who discovered Lascaux, complete confusion between the Dordogne and Vézère rivers...I could go on and on, but it's shameful that they would pay someone to "write" something like this and makes you wonder if ANY of the travel info they put out, on the website or in their guidebooks, has any value whatsoever.
#5
You are overlooking the possibility that this may be deliberate misinformation, meant to throw the tourist hordes off the track. Or perhaps they suspect plagiarism by other publisher and want to see if the misinformation is repeated elsewhere.
#7
Original Poster
Join Date: Jan 2003
Posts: 49,560
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Fra, I've worked in the publishing business for 35+ years, and it's not exactly part and parcel of the trade to impart deliberate misinformation. I guess plagiarism is a concern, but publishing misinformation isn't the kind of tactic a reputable publisher is likely to take to ferret it out.
#9
I gave up on travel publishers long ago -- besides almost never correcting errors, they accept outdated information for years and years due to "copy & paste" updates which are never checked. You would think that things would get better, but it is just the opposite since it has become so easy to copy "information" from anywhere.
#10
Perhaps one of our experts here needs to post a lot more about the region so Fodors can lift it and put it into one of their for-revenue publications. Who knows, they might even get a free copy.
#11
Join Date: Aug 2003
Posts: 2,893
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Welcome to the current state of publishing. The editors should be ashamed. Unfortunately, the cost of paying someone to get experience is no longer in the budget, and the cost of paying someone who already has plenty of experience never was in the budget. Oy vey, don't get me started.
#13
Original Poster
Join Date: Jan 2003
Posts: 49,560
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
But Robert, even if you picked info from the Internet, which, yes, is unreliable, you'd be able to print better, more reliable info than this article has. How can you get the market days in Sarlat wrong, for example? It's preposterous!
And yes, I get that it's the current state of publishing, which is deplorable. And yes, the editors should be ashamed. I am thankful still to have clients who care that I care what they print.
And yes, I get that it's the current state of publishing, which is deplorable. And yes, the editors should be ashamed. I am thankful still to have clients who care that I care what they print.
#14
Join Date: Jan 2010
Posts: 425
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Yikes!!! So glad we have you, StCirq. Have been reading many of your posts and enjoying them. We're heading to the Dordogne the second week of May for five nights and sure wish it were longer. Strange (maybe not, given the article) that I rely more on Fodor's Forum than on any travel book...including Rick Steves!
#16
I like the Fodors articles especially if I know something about the subject. I'm amazed when there is something correct in them, I used to write up the errors but now I just love them, a bit like "1066 and all that". The recent one on wine tasting etiquette was wonderful and must have been written by a teetotaller in darkest Peru.
#19
Join Date: Jan 2007
Posts: 78,320
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Don't bite the hand that feeds! You could have phrased your disgust with Fodor's editors in a much better way than the scathing way you did.
Not that your points, if valid, are not valid.
I mean to malign the whole Fodor's enterprise for one article - throwing the proverbial baby out with the bathwater.
Anyway your comments left a bad taste in my month, accurate or not. Be kinder, gentler to make the same points.
Cheers
Not that your points, if valid, are not valid.
I mean to malign the whole Fodor's enterprise for one article - throwing the proverbial baby out with the bathwater.
Anyway your comments left a bad taste in my month, accurate or not. Be kinder, gentler to make the same points.
Cheers
#20
Join Date: Aug 2003
Posts: 2,893
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
<i><font color=#555555>"Don't bite the hand that feeds!"</font></i>
Excuse me, but who's feeding whom here? Random House DOES NOT pay its longtime/experienced travel writers on this board. IMO, it's the contributors who are doing the feeding here.
<i><font color=#555555>"your comments left a bad taste in my month, accurate or not"</font></i>
Your mouth taste might matter if you were someone's boss in this matter. Since you are not…
<i><font color=#555555>"Be kinder, gentler to make the same points."</font></i>
Bringing mistakes to someone's attention in a "kinder, gentler" manner certainly has its place, especially if you are an employee with a boss. However, mistakes of this magnitude in the presence of veteran traveler contributors who know more, suggest a shocking tolerance from the powers-that-be for the quick, cheap, and inept. I think a little verbal outrage is appropriate here, and there's nothing quite like a slap from someone smarter to make someone not-as-smart think twice. Loyal researchers and committed contributors deserve more respect.
Excuse me, but who's feeding whom here? Random House DOES NOT pay its longtime/experienced travel writers on this board. IMO, it's the contributors who are doing the feeding here.
<i><font color=#555555>"your comments left a bad taste in my month, accurate or not"</font></i>
Your mouth taste might matter if you were someone's boss in this matter. Since you are not…
<i><font color=#555555>"Be kinder, gentler to make the same points."</font></i>
Bringing mistakes to someone's attention in a "kinder, gentler" manner certainly has its place, especially if you are an employee with a boss. However, mistakes of this magnitude in the presence of veteran traveler contributors who know more, suggest a shocking tolerance from the powers-that-be for the quick, cheap, and inept. I think a little verbal outrage is appropriate here, and there's nothing quite like a slap from someone smarter to make someone not-as-smart think twice. Loyal researchers and committed contributors deserve more respect.