Amalfi or Cinque Terre after chathedrals and museums

Well you can;t do the Amalfi coast by train because there is none. You would have to take a train to either Naples, change for local train to Sorrento then bus down the coast. Or train to Salerno and bus up the coast. Or - you could take a ferry from either, but it might be a pain with luggage.

We've done the area several times in May and loved it. but we had a car that we used to see Naples, Pompeii and drive along the coast to the various small towns. Just took a ferry to Capri.

Rolo- We have stayed in the Cinque Terre in Montorosso.
We loved it.It is very relaxing and laid back.
It seems more accessible to me than the Amalfi coast.
Don't get me wrong we have been to Sorrento,Capri,Pompeii and Positano. The Coastline to me along the Amalfi is extremely steep, especially for walking.We bused in and out of Positano. Granted we did not walk all the paths to each village of the Cinque Terre but the train made it easy to get around in the C.T.. They are noted for being late, but we relaxed in the Train Station and had Gin & Tonica's until they arrived.
Each coastline is equally beautiful,I don't think you will be disappointed in which ever you choose.
I'm not sure but the Cinque Terre may also be more affordable to stay in.Do your research and choose a village--we chose Monterosso because it is more active than other villages and larger, more restaurant choices,etc.
I would have to dig deeper to find where we stayed but I could do that, if you're interested?!?!
Ciao Sally

I would head to the Lighurian coast and base in Rapallo or Santa Maria Lighure. Beautiful area, relaxing and enjoyable.

It rather depends on where you are beginning and ending: flying into Pisa or Firenze and heading for Rome? Then perhaps you should keep going to the Amalfi. Or starting in Rome and ending up in Firenze? Then maybe you should go to le Cinque Terre.

How much do you want to be around tourists? Both areas get jam-packed with them, and yet the Mediterranean is a verrrrrry long coast, with several islands, including some just off Tuscany.

People come to Liguria and pack into le Cinque Terre, which are very tiny towns, and there is much more elbow room in the towns that surround Lerici, and much better food in Chiaviari, more cultural attractions within reach of Genova. Likewise, there are island off Tuscany for relaxation and all-Italian fun, or lesser known but gorgeous places around the Amalfi area with delicious traditional food and very few affluent foreign tourists.

If you look at pictures and do a little more research, you'll begin to get a sense of the different feeling between the sybaritic Amalfi coast and the more rustic Ligurian coast.

Actually "Chiaviari" is spelled "Chiavari", just mentioning the correct spelling for anyone that wants to research this city and the surrounding area. And the area east of Chiavari is quite interessting and rather an area where you don't find tourist very much although one would need a car to explore it.

Yes, thanks for correcting my finger slip!

Ciao!
Just returning from Italia and having experienced both locations you mention, I would say without reservation, Le Cinque Terre. It's more diverse, has plenty of unique towns, accessible via various forms of transportation, full of adventure, beauty and memories.

Amalfi, while picturesque and also amazing, is not as diverse and even a stop in Capri, is a one-day adventure, where you will have 5 little towns in Le Cinque Terre.

If you were to stay at the Porto Rosso in Montorosso al Mare, you would fall in love with the experience and want to return again and again.

Take the train, walk to the towns, eat your self silly on delicious seafood and pesto everything. Then wash it down with ... well, you get the idea.

A presto!

LL