Cruises Forums

Start a new topic Change Forum
Advanced search

One more comparison of Carnival ships

Jump to last reply

Thanks for all the prior advice. I am being such a nervous Nellie and still having a hard time with final decision because the exact dates and itineraries I would like do not match with the exact ships I want. I keep reading reviews and re-thinking each choice. Now have more specific questions.

How great is the itinerary that does Belize (cave tubing?) Cozumel, Costa Mayo or Roatan compared with one in the more Eastern Caribbean like Turks, Caymans, Montego Bay, Jamaica, etc?

We have not been to any of the ports and I do not care a bit. My only reason for one over the other is what I thought DD would like, and a friend of hers went to Belize and loved it. OTOH, she loves any beach and I've read Turks and Caicos are amazing.

I also wanted as much time as possible, but I guess six days rather than seven isn't such a big difference.

Boils down to
1. Dream out of Port of Canaveral to Mexico area 7nts
(Fantastic ship and first choice itinerary, but at least $200-$300 pp more for airfare and transportation, cheaper hotel perhaps.) The extra total cost of around $800-$1000 would pay for some nice dinners or excursions on Breeze or extra for hotel stay in Miami.
2. Breeze out of Miami to E. Caribbean 6 nts
(Fantastic ship, great price and easy flights, but second choice itinerary. Cost of hotel might be more than at POC, but Miami would be warmer.)
3. Liberty out of Miami to Mexico area 7 nts
(Favored itinerary, easy flights, but older ship)

How is weather in your experience or to your knowledge, in the Gulf in early March compared with Caribbean in March? DH says winds are always stronger in Gulf. Is he right?

I hate Miami airport and Ft Lauderdale was so easy last time we fly into it, that is affecting my thoughts? How much of a pain is it to go from Orlando to Port Canaveral?

Right now, I am leaning toward newer ship, Breeze, flying into Ft Lauderdale, staying the night at a hotel on the beach near the port, and not overthinking itinerary.

If you think the other itinerary is lots better, then how different is Liberty from Dream?

Is it worth the extra cost and land travel time for the itinerary to Mexico on Dream?

5 Replies |Back to top

| Add a Reply

Sign in to comment.

Recent Activity

  • Announcement:
  • Fodor's Go List 2015 Has Been Announced
    by Emily_D Fodor's Editor | Posted on Dec 19, 14 at 05:08 PM
View all Cruises activity »
  1. 1 AMA Waterways River Cruises
  2. 2 Newest Aida cruise ship AidaPrima
  3. 3 Trip Report Carnival Ecstasy, Fun Times
  4. 4 Shore excursions from Livorno, OTHER than Florence?
  5. 5 Transatlantic cruises late Oct. to mid-Nov. & Celebrity ship choice
  6. 6 choosing a stateroom on a ship
  7. 7 Sailing out of San Juan, PR
  8. 8 Alaska
  9. 9 "Shore Excursions in Italy.net"
  10. 10 Trip Report Trip report: Viking Portraits of Southern France
  11. 11 Hop on Hop Off Buses
  12. 12 Trip Report Alaska Shore excursion on the cheap
  13. 13 Choosing a stateroom on Rhine River cruise
  14. 14 Trip Report Sea Spirit to Antarctica
  15. 15 Trip Report Caribbean Princess Trip Report 2014
  16. 16 Alaska cruise excrusions
  17. 17 Carnival Miracle from LA to Mexico?
  18. 18 Trip Report Bad experience on Carnival!!!!!!!
  19. 19 Roundtrip to Alaska or one way
  20. 20 seascanner.com
  21. 21 Noordam VF4038
  22. 22 hotel park and cruise? Seattle
  23. 23 Norwegian Jewel or Canvial Freedom?
  24. 24 Mediterranean cruise
  25. 25 Viking River Cruise--Portugal
View next 25 » Back to the top