Cruises Forums

Start a new topic Change Forum
Advanced search

New to Fodors: Celebrity or RCL?

Jump to last reply

Hi All! I am fairly new to Fodors. My husband and I both in our early 30's are planning a week vacation the 3rd week of March 2013. We are trying to decide between another cruise or just going to an island. We have taken two Caribbean cruises on Princess staying in mini suites and loved them both.
Things we love about cruising:
1. Being on the water
2. Anytime Dining & Specialty Dining
3. Adult only swim/lounging areas
4. Spa & Fitness center
5. ALWAYS something to do (we can only take laying out in the sun for so many hours)
6. ALWAYS some kind of night life after dinner
7. Excursions
8. Being taken care of, service, being pampered

Things we do not love:
1. Only a few hours at each island
2. Sometimes the crowds on sea days

If we decide to cruise for 7 days, we would like to try a different cruise line. We are considering:

Celebrity on the new ship Reflection sailing from Miami to San Juan, St Maarten, and St Kitts with 3 days at Sea

RCL on Freedom of Seas sailing to Labadee, Falmouth Jamaica, George Town Grand Cayman, and Cozumel Mexico

RCL on either Oasis or Allure

Looking for some advice and help on which cruise to choose if we decide that is what we want to do for our vacation, Or should we just pick an island to go to? Thanks!!

18 Replies |Back to top

| Add a Reply

Sign in to comment.

Recent Activity

  • Announcements:
  • Introducing MeganM
    by Emily_D Fodor's Editor | Posted on Apr 24, 15 at 03:23 PM
  • Writers Needed for Japan
    by Emily_D Fodor's Editor | Posted on Mar 26, 15 at 02:38 PM
View all Cruises activity »
  1. 1 Are drinks packages worth buying?
  2. 2 Viking or Uniworld for Egypt/Nile
  3. 3 St. Petersburg, Russia Port Tour
  4. 4 Greece Italy Cruise
  5. 5 Cruise: last minute price- 4 nights from Auckland to Melbourne 1 Feb 2016
  6. 6 Gratutities on Quantum Class
  7. 7 Ferry from Copenhagen to Oslo
  8. 8 southern caribbean shore excursions
  9. 9 I have made a deposit on my first Cruise (RCI Panama Canal)
  10. 10 Anyone had problems with Affordable Tours?
  11. 11 Transportation options around Miami and Ft Lauderdale
  12. 12 Best time of year to avoid drunken crowds? Cruise lines to avoid?
  13. 13 Cruise room options for three people
  14. 14 12 Day Cruise with 2 Kids under 3
  15. 15 Tauck Danube cruise
  16. 16 Dresscode on HAL Alaska Cruise
  17. 17 First Time Alaska Cruise
  18. 18 Trip Report The PINK But Still FUN Ugly Duckling
  19. 19 New charge on NCL
  20. 20 returning rental car in Southampton
  21. 21 Aug 1, Baltic cruise on Caribbean Princess
  22. 22 Trip Report Trip report: Viking Portraits of Southern France
  23. 23 Trip Report Royal Caribbean Changes!!!!
  24. 24 Trip Report Beware of Grand Circle Travel and Overseas Adventure Travel
  25. 25 Uniworld Bordeaux, Vineyard & Chateau vs. Burgundy & Provence River Cruise
View next 25 » Back to the top