Cruises Forums

Start a new topic Change Forum
Advanced search

New to Fodors: Celebrity or RCL?

Jump to last reply

Hi All! I am fairly new to Fodors. My husband and I both in our early 30's are planning a week vacation the 3rd week of March 2013. We are trying to decide between another cruise or just going to an island. We have taken two Caribbean cruises on Princess staying in mini suites and loved them both.
Things we love about cruising:
1. Being on the water
2. Anytime Dining & Specialty Dining
3. Adult only swim/lounging areas
4. Spa & Fitness center
5. ALWAYS something to do (we can only take laying out in the sun for so many hours)
6. ALWAYS some kind of night life after dinner
7. Excursions
8. Being taken care of, service, being pampered

Things we do not love:
1. Only a few hours at each island
2. Sometimes the crowds on sea days

If we decide to cruise for 7 days, we would like to try a different cruise line. We are considering:

Celebrity on the new ship Reflection sailing from Miami to San Juan, St Maarten, and St Kitts with 3 days at Sea

RCL on Freedom of Seas sailing to Labadee, Falmouth Jamaica, George Town Grand Cayman, and Cozumel Mexico

RCL on either Oasis or Allure

Looking for some advice and help on which cruise to choose if we decide that is what we want to do for our vacation, Or should we just pick an island to go to? Thanks!!

18 Replies |Back to top

| Add a Reply

Sign in to comment.

Recent Activity

View all Cruises activity »
  1. 1 Majesty of the Seas
  2. 2 Scuba diving in Nassau or Freeport? Is Atlantis worth the $$$
  3. 3 Cruise port to ferry in Haines, AK
  4. 4 Transportation : Best way to get from Seattle airport to cruise ship
  5. 5 Cruise room options for three people
  6. 6 Alaska cruise on Celebrity Solstice
  7. 7 Trip Report Holland America Southbound Cruise - early June
  8. 8 Need ideas for Charlotte Amalie, St. thomas due to cruise change.
  9. 9 rental cars at Lerwick & Scrabster Cruise Ports in Scotland
  10. 10 Trip Report Alaska Shore excursion on the cheap
  11. 11 Help with Glacier days on Alaskan cruise
  12. 12 Taking alcohol on board.
  13. 13 Trip Report Royal Caribbean Changes!!!!
  14. 14 Would you live on a cruise ship year round?
  15. 15 Viking River Cruise/Tulips and Windmils
  16. 16 Opinion of specific cruise lines?
  17. 17 First Time Mediterranean Cruiser
  18. 18 MIA to dock
  19. 19 Big ship or small ship?
  20. 20 Alaska in June
  21. 21 Scandinavia and St. Petersburg
  22. 22 Cruise Transfer with Alaska Cruise Transportation
  23. 23 Southern Caribbean Cruise tips - Celebrity
  24. 24 Cruise Planners Credit Card Data Breech
  25. 25 Celebrity Caribbean Cruise with NO Paid Excursions??
View next 25 » Back to the top