Cruises Forums

Post New Topic

Recent Activity

  • Announcement:
  • Recent Spam Attacks
    by mkataoka Fodor's Editor | Posted on Nov 28, 16 at 01:31 PM
View all Cruises activity »
  1. 1 Booking directly with cruise line or through an agency?
  2. 2 Need tour help for Diamond Princess roundtrip from Singapore itinerary
  3. 3 Shore Excursions in Juneau
  4. 4 What to pack South America
  5. 5 Trip Report SICKNESS ON VIKING!
  6. 6 Best Luxury Cruise to Greek Islands?
  7. 7 Cruisewear on Princess
  8. 8 Cruise parking, Fort Lauderdale
  9. 9 Cruise facts
  10. 10 Trip Report Santiago to Buenos Aires on the Sun in March 2016.
  11. 11 Antarctica-Expedition-Feb.2017-By OneOcean-
  12. 12 Quiet in the Forum
  13. 13 Trip Report Trip report. Our cruise on the Diamond Princess with a stay in Tokyo
  14. 14 Trip Report Viking handles Elbe low water badly
  15. 15 What is "roll call" on Cruise Critic?
  16. 16 Anyone had problems with Affordable Tours?
  17. 17 What to wear onboard Zaandam from Santiago to Buenos Aires.
  18. 18 Royal Princess 21 Days western Mediterranean and Greek Isles
  19. 19 Would you live on a cruise ship year round?
  20. 20 inoculations
  21. 21 St Petersburg & Scandinavian Gems
  22. 22 November Mediterranean Cruise
  23. 23 Scenic River Cruise USA Pricing Discrimination
  24. 24 Viking River Cruise Accident, Two Crew Killed
  25. 25 Ncl Jewel falling apart?
View next 25 » Back to the top

Mexican cruise, Carnival Ecstasy or RCCI Viking Serenade?

Jump to last reply

We are planning our first cruise in July(with our six children ages 7-19) and deciding between the 4 day Baja CA or the 7 day Mexican Riviera. Is the 7 day that much better for the cruise experience? Our ship choices are Carnival Ecstasy or Royal Viking Serenade. Any recent experience on either of these ships? Any comments would be greatly appreciated!
Sandy

  • Report Abuse


    Hi Sandy,

    First, it is a good idea to take a short cruise for the first time escpecially if you live in the LA area and do not have to fly. Four day would do perfectly.

    There are pros and cons for both mass-market cruise lines.

    Carnival's Ecstacy was built in 1991 therefore the ship is newer. The space ratio per passenger is higher therefore the ship will not be as crowded. The staterooms are 185 square feet and plenty of room for storage. The kids would have a better time. The ship is extremely eclectic or what you would call a "Las Vegas" motif (if that suits your fancy). The 24 hour pizza, calzone and salad restaurant is a plus.

    The Viking was built in 1982 and I doubt the ship will be in the fleet that much longer. Older ships are more difficult and expensive to maintain. The ship is definitely more elegant than the Ecstacy. The cabins are the size of a bathroom and you certainly would be cramped with more than 2 in a cabin. The ship is dressier than Carnival. The service is average, same as Carnival. The food is only rated average but some say it is a matter of taste. The buffet lines are usually shorter on RCCL. The production shows are not as exciting or as varied as Carnival. This again is a matter of taste.

    Other than the above, the cruise experience is the same.

    Paul

1 Reply |Back to top

Sign in to comment.

Advertisement