Cruises Forums

Post New Topic

Recent Activity

View all Cruises activity »
  1. 1 Trip Report Alaska Shore excursion on the cheap
  2. 2 tips for first cruisers
  3. 3 Panama Canal Cruise Excursion recs
  4. 4 British Passport Validity
  5. 5 Juneau Excursions: Mendenhall, Whale Watching, or both?
  6. 6 European River Cruises - strategy
  7. 7 Cruising New Zealand?
  8. 8 Alaskan cruise
  9. 9 Would you live on a cruise ship year round?
  10. 10 Excursion Shore
  11. 11 St Petersburg and Norway cruise?
  12. 12 Time in ports?
  13. 13 Rome to port at Civitavecchia
  14. 14 Choosing a river cruise company in Europe..
  15. 15 HAL Nieuw Amsterdam Room Query
  16. 16 Windstar cruise around Iceland
  17. 17 Polferries Guided 4 Day Tour
  18. 18 Trip Report Antarctica Trip Report, March 2015, 10 Days
  19. 19 Best Cruise Excursions in Panama Canal
  20. 20 Trip Report Mediterranean Ports Of Call, Carnival Vista
  21. 21 Glacier Trek vs. Glacier + Dog sledding?
  22. 22 Best Alaska Cruise with Kids!
  23. 23 Sep cruise/Juneau - dog sledding vs. Mendenhall ice cave trek
  24. 24 QM2 - Transport from Red Hook to LGA
  25. 25 Trip Report Viking Ocean Cruise nightmare
View next 25 » Back to the top

Disappointed HAL cruise on Westerdam-do cruise ships have unique culture?

Jump to last reply

We booked a deluxe suite on the HAL Westerdam for a week long cruise that was very disappointing. We sailed out of Fort Lauderdale on New Year's Eve and were expecting great service since that's what we've gotten on 3 other Holland America cruises. First--what worked well: we had good cabin service for the most part. Our cabin attendant was very attentive and did a good job to help us be comfortable.

Room service was disappointing on day one-----their representative answering the phone on day one did not know what hors d'oeuvres were (Deluxe suite occupants get free hot hors d'oeuvres each evening upon request). When we had the same problem on day two, we stopped using room service and switched to the concierge in the Neptune Lounge (another benefit for suites) and they were able to help us.

We noticed that the ship did not seem to be kept as clean as other HAL. Elevator buttons and hand rails were often smudged from hundreds of hands using them every day and those smudges stayed there for days.

Dining room service, usually perfect on HAL really missed the mark. Reservations were fouled even when we had our reservation card in our hands and table service was not attentive. We often had to asked several times to get a request fulfilled.

Biggest dining disappointment---ate in the Pinnacle which has a $20 fee per person upcharge. I ordered a bone-in ribeye but was served a regular ribeye. When I pointed out that it was not what I ordered, our waiter first told me that it was. When I asked where the bone was, he tried to convince me that there was a bone in this piece of beef. When I showed him that it was not what I ordered he left the table and then returned a few minutes later and said, "we're running low on bone-in ribeyes". Running low? I still wonder who they were saving the last ones for! Service again was just not up to standard. At the same meal the ship's captain and some of the senior officers were seated behind us. They spent the meal complaining about crews on other ships---VERY odd!

While I realize that this all may seem petty to most readers, I wonder if there is a way to know in advance about the culture of a ship? We really like Holland America and have never had poor service before. Is this just the culture of this ship? Have we just been lucky before?

4 Replies |Back to top

Sign in to comment.

Advertisement