Caribbean Islands Forums

Start a new topic Change Forum
Advanced search

Yet Another Person Needing Help Deciding Which Island

Jump to last reply

Hi,
After coming home from our tenth anniversary trip to Maui, the only way to beat my post-vacation blues to is to think about our next big vacation (probably June 2015 as I am a teacher and can really only go for spring break or summer). I am having a hard time narrowing down choices, the more I research the more confused I get (I know, a common problem). We just had an amazing 5 night stay at the Four Seasons on Maui and that's where our expectations are. We also stayed 4 nights prior at a condo resort (Honua Kai) so we are not total luxury snobs though. We are average hard working people (with no kids) who can save up for a trip. So why the Caribbean? I want something with a shorter flight than Maui and hopefully cheaper airfare. I have been to Aruba a long time ago (2001) but would prefer a different island this time.

My top wishes (sort of in order):
1. gorgeous white sandy beaches
2. clear turquoise waters
3. good snorkeling off the beach
4. accommodation on the beach, also with a pool that overlooks the beach/ocean
5. safety
6. nice restaurants
7. lack of stray dogs (I have an irrational fear of dogs instilled in me by my Mom. Even the friendliest dogs I will be afraid of).
8. not a ton of cruise ships (going in June)

What doesn't matter to me:
1. casinos
2. hiking
3. nightlife
4. scuba diving
5. shopping

Would most likely rent a car.

I won't mention the three islands I've been researching the most, kind of want to see if they match up. Thank you!!!!

24 Replies |Back to top

| Add a Reply

Sign in to comment.

Recent Activity

View all Caribbean Islands activity »
  1. 1 Not impressed with Aruba, too touristy. Period. Are we out of luck?
  2. 2 Jamaica to Other Island
  3. 3 Viceroy Sugar Beach or Dorado Beach, A Ritz-Carlton Reserve
  4. 4 Vespa Rental - Turks
  5. 5 Turks Caicos grace bay vs Long Bay or chalk sound?
  6. 6 Help on picking a adult only all inclusive resort
  7. 7 swim up rooms
  8. 8 Puerto Rico - January 13 - 21 - Itinerary
  9. 9 Where to spend a month or two this winter
  10. 10 Trip Report TOP 5 MUST-DO LIST FOR GRAND CAYMAN VACATION
  11. 11 Anyone else been to Secret Harbor in St. Thomas?
  12. 12 St. John USVI
  13. 13 Which Island?
  14. 14 Carribean vacation with infant
  15. 15 A nice hotel to stay in St Martin for one night ?
  16. 16 Buccament Bay in Kingston, St. Vincent and Grenadines
  17. 17 Cayman Islands in October
  18. 18 things to do in Nassau
  19. 19 August 2015 Honeymoon Trip Ideas
  20. 20 Trip Report I got robbed in St Maarten - St Martin on the French side
  21. 21 Best resorts for families with 3 small kids
  22. 22 Destination Wedding Planning: DR, Jamaica, Virgin Islands, or Barbados
  23. 23 Best island for early to mid November
  24. 24 snorkle choices in Antigua
  25. 25 Please help me decide to go to Cuba!
View next 25 » Back to the top