Caribbean Islands Forums

Start a new topic Change Forum
Advanced search

Which island? mix of fun and beach and locals

Jump to last reply

So, I am looking for a vacation spot in March. I have spent a decent amount of time in the Caribbean, mostly for scuba vacations, and this time it is my girlfriend and I (she is not a scuba diver - so that is not relevant).
What we are looking for. Not wanting the mega resort world (so no Dominican or Jamaica). Want something close to the beach (or on it of course!), something were we can hang with a mix of locals and tourists and "feel" the experience at a local beach bar, etc. Want some night life - but don't need huge big clubs, but a little late night drinking and dancing is a must.

Would like a little snorkeling and catamaran sailings along with beach lounging. I would like a place were I can explore a bit on our own (maybe rent a car) and if I am driving - I want a place where you drive on the right (would hate to spend my vacation in the hospital because I turned wrong on a roundabout!)

Don't need high end shopping, but perusing a few little beachy shops for a bit is fun. Want to be able to run to a grocery store to stock up on food for breakfast and snacks to save up for the nice meals out. No roach cheap motel, but not a 5 start - think Hampton Inn type.

Where I have been and what I liked (to give you a feel for me)

Bonaire - been there 5x - love it- but Scuba diving in only reason I was there - love the place, but not what I am looking for this time - no real night life.

Roatan - see Bonaire - I never left CocoView resort

Naussau - only there for a night as I left for a scuba liveaboard

Maui - Love it - exactly what I am looking for - with maybe more night life needed (but maybe I did not find it)

Barbados - again loved it - but didn't feel like I should be driving around - was a tad spread out - but my part (south of bridgetown) I had a blast

DR - stayed at Hard Rock - we loved it, had a great time, but want something maybe less mega resort (and where we can explore the local area more)

Curacau - had fun - was there for a wedding, explored the area a little more - hated the traffic, but didn't get out an about other than near our villa - but had potential - maybe something more "rain forest" tropical thou.

Have visited several places on cruises, so never really got to explore - been to:
Antigua (thought it was rough for us)
Torotola - seemed beautiful, but maybe a little too low key??
St Thomas, potential, but just went to beach
Cozumel - again - potential, mix of fun and sand - but maybe not much island exploring
Grand Cayman - again - beautiful, nice, and clean, - think I could like it - but maybe a little expensive??

So - places I am thinking
Key West - cool bars, but not much beach or exploring
Puerto Rico - thinking a couples days in Old San Juan then either Culebra or another area for the rest
Playa Del Carmen - my sis is going there next week, can tell me more
Cancun - maybe to much mega resort?
St Martin - pricey, but maybe not - not to familiar with it

16 Replies |Back to top

| Add a Reply

Sign in to comment.

Recent Activity

  • Announcements:
  • Writers Needed for Mexico
    by Emily_D Fodor's Editor | Posted on Jul 24, 14 at 12:19 PM
  • Writers Needed for Georgia Coast
    by Emily_D Fodor's Editor | Posted on Jul 18, 14 at 03:12 PM
  • Writers Needed for Rwanda and Uganda
    by Emily_D Fodor's Editor | Posted on Jul 18, 14 at 03:12 PM
View all Caribbean Islands activity »
  1. 1 Where to go in February/March
  2. 2 Trip Report A U.S. citizen's tour to Cuba
  3. 3 Trip Report It's Excellent in the Exumas ~ A week on Staniel Cay (+ Atlantis)
  4. 4 Anguilla Honeymoon in June
  5. 5 My First Vacation Alone & First Vacation in 13 Years
  6. 6 looking for rustic on the beach, north side
  7. 7 Please help me decide to go to Cuba!
  8. 8 Best place for two single girls in early 20s?!
  9. 9 Seeking luxury resort with private villas/pools
  10. 10 St. Thomas Frenchman's Reef Marriot Resort - Need advice
  11. 11 Which island?
  12. 12 Puerto Rico Public Transportation
  13. 13 Planning possible retirement in USVI
  14. 14 Trip Report St. Thomas is dangerous
  15. 15 Need Help..Large group, wedding?
  16. 16 St. Croix and sea grass
  17. 17 Multiple flights in Caribbean
  18. 18 Rainforest Question: Better to do a Tour or go on your own?
  19. 19 Bahamas Resort
  20. 20 Which country?
  21. 21 Seeking general advice on one-to-two-month Caribbean villa rental
  22. 22 back to TCI, for 3rd time...
  23. 23 Antigua or St Martin
  24. 24 South Beach Hotel Barbados
  25. 25 Bequia or Virgin Gorda?
View next 25 » Back to the top