Caribbean Islands Forums

Start a new topic Change Forum
Advanced search

Two Totally Different Trips: Barbados vs. Jamaica

Jump to last reply

I need some advice about going at Christmas on a mother daughter trip (25 and 50 yrs) to the Carribean. I have spent about 20 hours of research on this and have narrowed it down to two very different vacations that we could do- and would love advice. Both trips come out to very similar prices when including food, airfare, and hotel.

1. Barbados

We would stay at Bougainvillea ( http://www.bougainvillearesort.com/ ). It is not all inclusive but we'd do a combination of buying drinks at the bar, making a little in our room, and going into the Gap for meals.

(Keep in mind this all my opinions from reading online- I know some of my ideas may be false- but you can only know so much from researching.)

Perks: more glamourous island in my opinion and we love that we could be off of the resort a lot checking out the locals & restaurants. love that most places seem to be owned by bajans. we hear the food options are great!

2. Negril, Jamaica

We would stay at Beaches ( http://www.beaches.com/main/ng/ng-home.cfm - which is the more family oriented chain by Sandals). It is all inclusive and includes all drinks, all activities (all watersports and a night time show/event every night), and all food at the restaurants on property.

Perks: We've done AI in the past and although we don't have a strong preference, there is something appealing about getting off the plane and not thinking as much- esp. about money. Love all of the included activities, the night time events, and of course the unlimited alcohol.

I feel torn because although I feel like Barbados would be slightly more unique, cultured, and sophisticated of a vacation in certain ways, but I also have heard that Sandals does Caribbean vacations really well- they truly cater to what most people would really love on a tropical vacation and they make it so relaxing and easy for the visitor. Sandals seems kind of like a summer camp for adults! With that said, I can't decide if it would make me sad that we couldn't explore the rest of the island like we could with Barbados.

I feel like I have two totally different trips here. Option 1 reminds me of our trip to Playa Linda in Aruba in 2010. Option 2 reminds me of our trip to the Solaris resort in Cancun in 2009. We loved both is the problem! Any final feedback on where to choose? Sorry for such a long post, but thought it was better to give all of the information if I'm imploring for everyone's advice.

11 Replies |Back to top

| Add a Reply

Sign in to comment.

Recent Activity

  • Announcement:
  • Fodor's Go List 2015 Has Been Announced
    by Emily_D Fodor's Editor | Posted on Dec 19, 14 at 05:08 PM
View all Caribbean Islands activity »
  1. 1 Best Singles Vacation 35-50 in Caribbean
  2. 2 not tell a litigation a which basically ch
  3. 3 Jamaica all inclusive
  4. 4 Barbados/St. John/Turks/Puerto Rico/Curacao/
  5. 5 Why Barbados?
  6. 6 Bahamas Out Islands OR Turks & Caicos for family of teens?!
  7. 7 Can you travel to Cuba without a group?
  8. 8 Cuba Opening Up
  9. 9 Looking for deep sea fishing, beaches, culture (ALL CARIBBEAN SUGGESTIONS)
  10. 10 Half Moon in Jamaica
  11. 11 ROMANTIC DINNER FOR VERY SPECIAL OCCASION- seeking advice
  12. 12 Aruba Beach Club - Eagle Beach
  13. 13 Trip Report Just back from The Somerset
  14. 14 BodyHoliday, St. Lucia or other wellness spa recommendations?
  15. 15 Late October Honeymoon in the Caribbean
  16. 16 Advice needed: Caribbean island / beaches for small children/toddlers
  17. 17 Sandals Resorts
  18. 18 Falmouth, Jamaica that bad???
  19. 19 Where is the most romantic place for dinner in Bermuda?
  20. 20 Best place for two single girls in early 20s?!
  21. 21 Trip Report Trip Report - Eastern Cuba 2006
  22. 22 Please help me decide to go to Cuba!
  23. 23 Cuba in 10 days
  24. 24 1st time to Caribbean/Turks & Caicos - suggestions
  25. 25 Turks/Caicos or Dominican Republic
View next 25 » Back to the top