Caribbean Islands Forums

Start a new topic Change Forum
Advanced search

Torn Between Islands...

Jump to last reply

Hi Everyone,

I have been trying to plan a vacation for a few weeks now and I just can't decide which Caribbean island I want to visit. My girlfriend and I are in our mid 20's. We have done the party scene already so something with a more relaxing feel is the way to go for us this time. So far, I am torn between the following(not in any order): Aruba(been once and liked it), St. John(never been), Mexico(been numerous times), Antigua(never been), St. Lucia(never been), Bahamas(never been). I am also open to suggestions. Budget is around 2k each person. I am trying to see new places, but I am not opposed to going back to a place I have been. Looking to travel mid May. To help narrow this down, some facts about my travel likes/dislikes:

Likes:

-Modern hotel(we like low rise better but at this point we will settle for high rise). To be honest we would love to be able to open our backdoor and be on the beach. We stayed at the Divi in Aruba and loved that aspect.
-Friendly island, somewhere we can walk out of the hotel at night.
-All inclusive(but does not have to be if restaurants nearby and worth it)/ meal plan would be nice if no AI
-Casinos
-Nice Beaches(we prefer the hotel to have its own attached beach)
-Something to do at night but does not have to be party central! We don't want to be back in the room by 11pm.

Dislikes:
-Renting a car(which I think dismisses St John.)
-Poor service
-Leaving from NY so no connecting flights

Sorry for the long post, but hopefully someone can chime in...

Thanks to all in advance!

7 Replies |Back to top

| Add a Reply

Sign in to comment.

Recent Activity

  • Announcement:
  • Fodor's 100 Hotel Award Winners Announced
    by Emily_D Fodor's Editor | Posted on Sep 17, 14 at 01:05 PM
View all Caribbean Islands activity »
  1. 1 Which Sandals Jamaica is the best
  2. 2 Antigua - First Trip - Which Beach and Which Bed ?
  3. 3 Memorable anniversary dinner on St. Thomas?
  4. 4 BEST RESORTS FOR SINGLES EARLY-MID 20s
  5. 5 Dominican Republic villa rental
  6. 6 Trip Report fox. car rental montego bay jamaica
  7. 7 Stop Jet Ski's in Anguilla
  8. 8 Turks & Caicos
  9. 9 7 days solo...Cuba or Puerto Rico, guys???
  10. 10 Restaurants in St. Barth's?
  11. 11 Travel to the Caribbean the week before Christmas
  12. 12 Trip Report Long Island Bahanas
  13. 13 All Inclusive in Caribbean or Mexico?
  14. 14 Honeymoon Help- Caribbean Destination with Walk-in Snorkeling & Nightlife
  15. 15 Need Caribbean island/hotel suggestions for February trip with 2 year old
  16. 16 St. Bart's-- how can I get La Pinta vanilla rum?
  17. 17 Which carribbean island to chose.. dilema's...
  18. 18 DIY Wedding for Two – Can I pull this off without a Wedding Planner?
  19. 19 Punta Cana excursions
  20. 20 Girlfriends All Inclusive Resort Punta Cana or Mexico
  21. 21 Van rental for 8 in Puerto Rico
  22. 22 Restaraunts & Rental Cars in Aruba
  23. 23 Aruba suggestions
  24. 24 Trip Report I got robbed in St Maarten - St Martin on the French side
  25. 25 Nassau
View next 25 » Back to the top