Caribbean Islands Forums

Start a new topic Change Forum
Advanced search

St. Lucia vs St. Maarten vs Curacao or Guadeloupe...help!

Jump to last reply

I am planning a trip for me boyfriend and I for the last week in March into April...roughly 6-8 days. I'm torn between these three islands although if someone has a suggestions I haven't mentioned please let me know, open to anything!

We've both done a fair share of traveling and aren't looking to plop down on a flat, small island for the entirety. We're both active and would like to do some snorkeling, hike, see a rain forest if possible, etc...We definitely don't want an over run Americanized island...although, we are definitely looking to have some nice meals and relax as well!

I'm very drawn to the lush topography of St. Lucia...the Pitons look stunning, and it seems it has a lot to offer aside from the beach. That being said when we are beaching it which we plan to do roughly half the time I'd like something really beautiful... perhaps a little tiki bar around or kayaks to rent....the water in St. Lucia seems a bit darker as opposed to the bright turquoise of some of the other islands. Can any one suggest a beautiful beach? I've also read about some complaints regarding the driving around the island. It seems things are quite difficult to get too....? Was also considering a day to the Grenadines...if anyone has advice on that. Also any budget accommodation anyone can suggest...the hotels are pretty pricey..

St. Maarten looks stunning as well and a day trip to Anguilla would be perfect. The beaches of SXM are exactly what I am looking for, my only draw back is the commercialization of the island...it seems a bit more touristy and rowdy? I don't want to feel bored after a few days....

Curacao has also intrigued me as the culture would be great and it seems a bit more affordable. I haven't done too much research into it yet. Same with Guadeloupe...

Thanks all!

Katie

6 Replies |Back to top

| Add a Reply

Sign in to comment.

Recent Activity

View all Caribbean Islands activity »
  1. 1 Not impressed with Aruba, too touristy. Period. Are we out of luck?
  2. 2 walkable hotels
  3. 3 Island Hopping Honeymoon!!
  4. 4 St. John USVI
  5. 5 Turks Caicos grace bay vs Long Bay or chalk sound?
  6. 6 The right adults-only resort
  7. 7 Jamaica to Other Island
  8. 8 Viceroy Sugar Beach or Dorado Beach, A Ritz-Carlton Reserve
  9. 9 Vespa Rental - Turks
  10. 10 Help on picking a adult only all inclusive resort
  11. 11 swim up rooms
  12. 12 Puerto Rico - January 13 - 21 - Itinerary
  13. 13 Where to spend a month or two this winter
  14. 14 Trip Report TOP 5 MUST-DO LIST FOR GRAND CAYMAN VACATION
  15. 15 Anyone else been to Secret Harbor in St. Thomas?
  16. 16 Which Island?
  17. 17 Carribean vacation with infant
  18. 18 A nice hotel to stay in St Martin for one night ?
  19. 19 Buccament Bay in Kingston, St. Vincent and Grenadines
  20. 20 Cayman Islands in October
  21. 21 things to do in Nassau
  22. 22 August 2015 Honeymoon Trip Ideas
  23. 23 Trip Report I got robbed in St Maarten - St Martin on the French side
  24. 24 Best resorts for families with 3 small kids
  25. 25 Destination Wedding Planning: DR, Jamaica, Virgin Islands, or Barbados
View next 25 » Back to the top