Caribbean Islands Forums

Start a new topic Change Forum
Advanced search

St. Lucia or Antigua?

Jump to last reply

Assuming we, like Sally in Seattle who just posted, can manage the trip to the Caribbean from the West Coast, which of these islands offers the nicest "beach" experience?
The two resorts I'm considering are Anse Chastanet and Hermitage Bay.
We're only going for a week and want clear beautiful water.
I know the sand at AC is volcanic but the photos I've seen of the water are gorgeous, although all look rather dark. Perhaps this is because the mountains limit the amount of sunlight?
We're traveling at the beginning of December.
We've visited St. Barths, which we love, and other Caribbean islands, but not these.

25 Replies |Back to top

| Add a Reply

Sign in to comment.

Recent Activity

View all Caribbean Islands activity »
  1. 1 Vacation Ideas
  2. 2 1st time to Caribbean/Turks & Caicos - suggestions
  3. 3 Jamaica vs. Barbados
  4. 4 Tips for bahamas
  5. 5 Trip Report St. Martin/Nevis Trip Report
  6. 6 First time to Puerto Rico need advise please
  7. 7 condo / villa with kids, on the beach
  8. 8 Trip Report My trip report from 10/23 - 11/1/14 - St. John USVI's
  9. 9 Cupecoy Beach
  10. 10 Bay Gardens Beach Hotel in St Lucia
  11. 11 Seven Mile Beach Questions
  12. 12 Barbados with two kids under 4.
  13. 13 walkable hotels
  14. 14 Colony Club Barbados OR Sandals Great Exuma Bahamas????
  15. 15 Trip Report Back from San Juan
  16. 16 St Thomas
  17. 17 Cheapest excursions in Punta Cana?
  18. 18 Cuba - Questions about Phone/Internet/Currency
  19. 19 St Thomas need condo advice and trip plans
  20. 20 Turks and Caicos - Best Time to Book Accomodation
  21. 21 Grenada - Coyaba vs. Flamboyant
  22. 22 Aruba Restaurants
  23. 23 Aruba Restaraunts
  24. 24 Car Rental Puerto Rico
  25. 25 First time solo - the Bahamas
View next 25 » Back to the top