Caribbean Islands Forums

Post New Topic

Recent Activity

View all Caribbean Islands activity »
  1. 1 Snorkeling Couple need to narrow down island - May/April
  2. 2 island advice for 7 night end of march
  3. 3 What to do in Barbados with teens?
  4. 4 Cienfugas and Santiago--tours??
  5. 5 Trip Report Avoid Sandals Resort in St Lucia
  6. 6 Family of 5 undecided island
  7. 7 Using USA credit cards in Cuba
  8. 8 Anguilla Hotel recommendations
  9. 9 Suggestions for what to do/see in St. Martin/Maarten
  10. 10 Trip Report Staniel Cay, Exumas Trip Report & Photos (Feb 2017)
  11. 11 Tortola next week
  12. 12 Summer trip
  13. 13 HELP!!! Westin Dawn Beach, St. Maarten
  14. 14 DR vs. Mexico
  15. 15 Surf Fly Fishing
  16. 16 Christmas 2017
  17. 17 Honeymoon Help!!
  18. 18 Honeymoon Destinations?
  19. 19 All inclusive
  20. 20 BVI trip questions
  21. 21 Is a Rental Car Necessary in Nassau?
  22. 22 Anguilla - where to rent a car
  23. 23 Puerto Esperanza from Havana
  24. 24 10 pm arrival St. Maarten
  25. 25 family resort ideas?
View next 25 » Back to the top

St Croix vs. St John vs. Puerto Rico?!

Jump to last reply

Hi everyone! My boyfriend and I are looking to book a vacation in late February/March to either the USVI or Puerto Rico. I've been to the Bahamas (Eleuthra) and have been wanting to go back there or to St. Lucia, but we are limited to US territories (my boyfriend doesn't have a passport). The main goal for the vacation is to relax and find our own little slice of paradise surrounded by incredibly beautiful, secluded, pristine beaches with crystal blue waters that feel untouched. I also love mountains/nature reserves, so that would be nice to have around, though not critical. We aren't interested in touristy/resort-y spots with lots of people and activities, though we'd like access to a few restaurants or perhaps a farmer's market (we can rent a car if needed).

St. John looks amazing, though it's expensive and we aren't sure we can squeeze it. St Croix also looks great and a bit more affordable (from what I've read, St Thomas sounds like it's more about luxury resorts and a bit more crowded, which doesn't really appeal to us for this trip). I also think that Puerto Rico looks great (Culebra and Vieques in particular, but open to suggestions on the main land too). We are looking at Airbnbs and have a max of about $200/250 per night on accommodations.

The pictures all look so beautiful, but would love to hear thoughts from anyone who has been to any of these places on what you think would best suit us! :) Or, if another place (within US territory) comes to mind, would love to hear suggestions! Ideally, we'd love a place where it's not too difficult to get to and preferably we'd only need one flight and maybe a ferry ride to get there.

Thank you!!

-Emily

7 Replies |Back to top

Sign in to comment.

Advertisement