Caribbean Islands Forums

Post New Topic

Recent Activity

View all Caribbean Islands activity »
  1. 1 Trip Report Trip Report: St. John Villa Rental
  2. 2 Zika-Free All-Inclusive Vacation
  3. 3 Need Trip Ideas For Late July
  4. 4 How Early to Arrive at St Maarten Airport?
  5. 5 Which Caribbean island is best for my family?
  6. 6 Best place to buy a vacation property I can also rent out...with a twist
  7. 7 Island advice plz!
  8. 8 Cuba:Drinking water?
  9. 9 First time to PR
  10. 10 Trip Report St. John Trip Report
  11. 11 Aussie couple's 3/4 week trip
  12. 12 Cuba
  13. 13 Scrub Island Resort
  14. 14 St Kitts' Bakery
  15. 15 Which Island - Family Getaway
  16. 16 Looking for the perfect Island in the Carribean
  17. 17 Trip Report Coral Sands, Exuma
  18. 18 St. Thomas- place to stay, rental car & night cruise suggestions
  19. 19 Best Luxury Caribbean Resort
  20. 20 We adore St. John...looking for something new!
  21. 21 July Adventure
  22. 22 Turks & Caicos or another island for a short getaway from NYC?
  23. 23 Help me plan the right island(s)!
  24. 24 Family vacation for divers
  25. 25 Sandals Resort Lovers Tell All
View next 25 » Back to the top

Secrets Wild Orchid or Jewell Dunns River

Jump to last reply

Okay last question before I make this tough decision. I wish I could plan more trips like this and then this decision would be less important. Being that we have never been anywhere tropical this is a big decision for us. We want modern luxurious rooms but is Jewell rooms that outdated? I live in Las Vegas and I would rather stay at the Wynn or Palazzo vs staying at MGM or Mandalay Bay.

We are down to 2 places and I want to know everyone's opinion. Because I am having a hard time deciding.

Secrets Pluses:
Beautiful new modern rooms
Lots of Pools
Bigger beach
more alcohol choices
more of what we are used to staying in US

Secrets Minuses:
Man made beach
Large resort with 700 suites
AC is poor in rooms? (read reviews)
Plane noise

Jewell Pluses:
smaller more intimate resort (also a negative)
1-bedroom suite would be same price as preferred club at secrets
lots of romantic add-ons (cabanas, dinner on the beach, etc)
Closer to excisions
Sounds like exceptional service (although many reviews say bad service)
better beach

Jewell minuses:
small resort (will we have enough to do for 5 days)
smaller beach
locals bothering you on jetskis and through the fence
only 2 pools
limited food choices
lots of people say food is not too good??

Can anyone help me with my decision?

2 Replies |Back to top

Sign in to comment.

Advertisement