My wife and I are headed to St. Thomas for a 8 nights and are having a difficult time choosing between these resorts (I know there are others but I am getting these nights for free from Marriott). Both seem nice however, Renaissance sounds like it is older and in a better location while the Reef sounds like it has more to offer and can be more secluded. Any thoughts?
Thanks
Renaissance or Frenchman's Reef?
Recent Activity
View all Caribbean Islands activity »
- 1 June vacation trip for guys
- 2 Which island to visit???
- 3
It's Excellent in the Exumas ~ A week on Staniel Cay (+ Atlantis)
- 4 Four Seasons Nevis or Four Seasons Punta Mita, Mexico?
- 5
HONEYMOONERS on BUDGET...HELP
- 6 Multi Family Vacation- Caribbean
- 7 DR vs Riviera Maya - Which Resort?
- 8 Real St. Lucia Tours
- 9 Honeymoon Help!
- 10 Search Engines for Any Caribbean destination?
- 11 Anyone drive a rental car in Dominican Republic?
- 12 Grand Cayman
- 13 Sandals La Source Grenada
- 14 Sandos Playacar Beach resort
- 15 Gifts for Cubans - ElectricalOutlets
- 16 Honeymoon - St. Lucia, Martinique, St. Vincent & the Grenadines
- 17 Sisters trip can't seem to narrow down
- 18 quiet and relaxing
- 19 Dress Code - Little Dix Bay
- 20 Scam & Fraud in Cancun / Mexico = Watch Out For Mayan Palace!!
- 21 Planning a Thanksgiving 2013 Honeymoon- Caribbean or Mexico?
- 22 Need some guidance with my Puerto Rican vacation!
- 23 All Inclusive for small children?
- 24 Private tours in Jamaica
- 25 Harbor Condos from VRBO
I would choose Frenchman's Reef--it has a small, but much prettier beach, with an absolutely stunning view. IMHO, Renaissance's beach is awful!!!! Others may tell you Renaissance is better because of it's location (closer to town of Red Hook and ferry to St. John), but for strictly hotel & beach, I'd pick Frenchman's Reef.
Just came back from 5 nights at the Renaissance. Stayed for free on Marriott Rewards points. We picked the Renaissance over Frenchman's Reef/Morningstar because of its proximity to St. John and the BVIs.
We were not crazy about the resort. The rooms were spacious, but seemed like they could use a little renovating. The beach area was decent but no one swam in the water. Nearby Coki Beach is much prettier, but beware that you walk through a pretty run-down area to get to it. The pool looked nice -- never went in because the water was too cold.
Basically, comes down to what you plan on doing on your vacation. If you mainly want to relax at the resort, sounds like Frenchman's Reef would be the better choice.
If you plan on doing more exploring/island hopping the Renaissance might be better for you. There are quite a few good restaurants on the East End.
Can't speak to Ren. but FR has a great water taxi into Charlotte Amalie during the day. If accessibility to Red Hook and ferry is important, you might also check into Ritz- they honor Marriott points too.