Caribbean Islands Forums

Start a new topic Change Forum
Advanced search

Please help a beach vacation novice: Turks & Caicos vs. St. John vs. ...?

Jump to last reply

My boyfriend and I (both mid 30s, no children) are looking for a Caribbean vacation in May. I have never been on any sort of tropical/beach vacation south of New England. My boyfriend has been to and really likes St. John, but he didn't really like the Bahamas. I thought we had pretty much decided on Turks & Caicos (and that's what I've researched the most), but I keep second guessing myself. If we do got to T&C we might go for a couple nights at Parrot Cay for R&R (I found a good deal) and then back to a (less expensive) Provo resort for more excitement. Here's what we are looking for:

-SWIMMING! Both in the ocean and I would love to stay somewhere with a great pool for a dip at the end of the day (I love really cool pools).

-I have never snorkeled but I would like to do it and see some cool wildlife. My boyfriend likes to dive, but he's pretty much a novice. Also paddle boarding and kayaking would be great. I like to be in the water/on the beach as much as possible.

-Scenery/Nature. Is the beauty of the TCI beaches enough to make up for the dry flat landscape? I would like something to take photos of.

-Getting around a little bit by bike/foot would be nice.

-A little bit of low-key "nightlife" would be nice-- basically just some good seafood restaurants or quiet bars with good cocktails, other people around, just something to do.

-We are going in May, so I'd rather not go somewhere where it gets much hotter/stickier by that time of year.

Would you recommend TCI or St. John? Is there something else you'd recommend for us? I ruled out Aruba right away because it looks a little boring to me (I know many people who LOVE Aruba, but I like a little more nature). Is TCI too much like Aruba? I ruled out St. Lucia and Saba because I'd like more beachy-beaches, though the nature and scenery does appeal to me. The architecture and sense I get from looking at Curacao and to some extent Barbados also appeals to me.

Ugh! Help! I'm confused!

18 Replies |Back to top

| Add a Reply

Sign in to comment.

Recent Activity

  • Announcements:
  • Writers Needed for Georgia Coast
    by Emily_D Fodor's Editor | Posted on Jul 18, 14 at 03:12 PM
  • Writers Needed for Rwanda and Uganda
    by Emily_D Fodor's Editor | Posted on Jul 18, 14 at 03:12 PM
  • Writers Needed for Zimbabwe, Zambia and Tanzania
    by Emily_D Fodor's Editor | Posted on Jul 18, 14 at 03:11 PM
View all Caribbean Islands activity »
  1. 1 Bermuda(I know it's not CB) or Turks
  2. 2 Trip Report Sailing Sabbatical Over -- Back from the Bahamas
  3. 3 BEWARE - St. Maarten Car Rental with Dollar/Thrifty Car Rental
  4. 4 St. Thomas Frenchman's Reef Marriot Resort - Need advice
  5. 5 My First Vacation Alone & First Vacation in 13 Years
  6. 6 Turtle Cove vs Grace Bay
  7. 7 Destination like USVI or BVI (topography) where I can rent a private villa
  8. 8 Get info about weather.
  9. 9 Is this Itinerary too ambitious???
  10. 10 Trip Report St. Thomas is dangerous
  11. 11 Logistics of getting to Anguilla
  12. 12 Anyone stay in an apartment on Bermuda?
  13. 13 Water/beach conditions in Barbados
  14. 14 Yet Another Person Needing Help Deciding Which Island
  15. 15 June Honeymoon Help, Please
  16. 16 LIAT Air
  17. 17 What's going on in Bimini ?
  18. 18 Beach front Caribbean Villa for New Year's
  19. 19 Need help again!!
  20. 20 relaxed beaches in january
  21. 21 Better snorkeling - The Dominican Republic or Jamaica
  22. 22 AirBnb be aware of a scam on this site (not AirBnb's fault)
  23. 23 Cheapest excursions in Punta Cana?
  24. 24 Trip Report A U.S. citizen's tour to Cuba
  25. 25 Cap Estate or Soufriere?
View next 25 » Back to the top