Caribbean Islands Forums

Start a new topic Change Forum
Advanced search

Please help a beach vacation novice: Turks & Caicos vs. St. John vs. ...?

Jump to last reply

My boyfriend and I (both mid 30s, no children) are looking for a Caribbean vacation in May. I have never been on any sort of tropical/beach vacation south of New England. My boyfriend has been to and really likes St. John, but he didn't really like the Bahamas. I thought we had pretty much decided on Turks & Caicos (and that's what I've researched the most), but I keep second guessing myself. If we do got to T&C we might go for a couple nights at Parrot Cay for R&R (I found a good deal) and then back to a (less expensive) Provo resort for more excitement. Here's what we are looking for:

-SWIMMING! Both in the ocean and I would love to stay somewhere with a great pool for a dip at the end of the day (I love really cool pools).

-I have never snorkeled but I would like to do it and see some cool wildlife. My boyfriend likes to dive, but he's pretty much a novice. Also paddle boarding and kayaking would be great. I like to be in the water/on the beach as much as possible.

-Scenery/Nature. Is the beauty of the TCI beaches enough to make up for the dry flat landscape? I would like something to take photos of.

-Getting around a little bit by bike/foot would be nice.

-A little bit of low-key "nightlife" would be nice-- basically just some good seafood restaurants or quiet bars with good cocktails, other people around, just something to do.

-We are going in May, so I'd rather not go somewhere where it gets much hotter/stickier by that time of year.

Would you recommend TCI or St. John? Is there something else you'd recommend for us? I ruled out Aruba right away because it looks a little boring to me (I know many people who LOVE Aruba, but I like a little more nature). Is TCI too much like Aruba? I ruled out St. Lucia and Saba because I'd like more beachy-beaches, though the nature and scenery does appeal to me. The architecture and sense I get from looking at Curacao and to some extent Barbados also appeals to me.

Ugh! Help! I'm confused!

18 Replies |Back to top

| Add a Reply

Sign in to comment.

Recent Activity

  • Announcement:
  • Fodor's 100 Hotel Award Winners Announced
    by Emily_D Fodor's Editor | Posted on Sep 17, 14 at 01:05 PM
View all Caribbean Islands activity »
  1. 1 Dominican Republic villa rental
  2. 2 Trip Report fox. car rental montego bay jamaica
  3. 3 Stop Jet Ski's in Anguilla
  4. 4 Turks & Caicos
  5. 5 7 days solo...Cuba or Puerto Rico, guys???
  6. 6 Memorable anniversary dinner on St. Thomas?
  7. 7 Restaurants in St. Barth's?
  8. 8 Travel to the Caribbean the week before Christmas
  9. 9 Trip Report Long Island Bahanas
  10. 10 All Inclusive in Caribbean or Mexico?
  11. 11 Honeymoon Help- Caribbean Destination with Walk-in Snorkeling & Nightlife
  12. 12 Need Caribbean island/hotel suggestions for February trip with 2 year old
  13. 13 St. Bart's-- how can I get La Pinta vanilla rum?
  14. 14 Which carribbean island to chose.. dilema's...
  15. 15 DIY Wedding for Two – Can I pull this off without a Wedding Planner?
  16. 16 Punta Cana excursions
  17. 17 Girlfriends All Inclusive Resort Punta Cana or Mexico
  18. 18 Which Sandals Jamaica is the best
  19. 19 Van rental for 8 in Puerto Rico
  20. 20 Restaraunts & Rental Cars in Aruba
  21. 21 Aruba suggestions
  22. 22 Trip Report I got robbed in St Maarten - St Martin on the French side
  23. 23 Nassau
  24. 24 Antigua - First Trip - Which Beach and Which Bed ?
  25. 25 LIAT Air
View next 25 » Back to the top