Overall our impression of Ottley's was quite favorable. Great staff, food, ambiance, pool. If you would like some negatives, there are only a few I can come up with. It's a bit isolated from town or other resort areas you might want to visit. We only ended up going into town twice during our week because of the distance involved. We did enjoy our escorted rain forest tour but didn't find a lot of other hiking opportunities nearby. We didn't find the snorkeling to be all that great anywhere on the island. We only ended up snorkeling one time on an organized function that Ottley's put on. We also had to deal with some noisy roosters doing their early morning thing at a nearby farm. They weren't right next door, but still loud enough to be heard. I always travel with earplugs, which took care of the problem. Our visit took place several years ago so the barnyard issue may not be a problem anymore.

We stayed at Ottley's in 03 and thought the rooms were incredible. We stayed in a large, very private room with small lap pool, whirlpool with wonderful views. Beautiful grounds and good food. The owners are also very accommodating and friendly. As the previous poster noted it is not near town but that adds to its beauty. There are not incredible beaches or snorkeling on St. Kitts. We did day trip to Nevis and there are other day trips you can take. Don't know PI so can't comment on it.

Thanks for your replies. I think that its distance from town won't bother us as long as the food there is good--which it sounds like it is.
NM: Do you remember if you stayed in a Royal Suite (the whole cottage) or a Supreme Room (the master bedroom portion of the cottage)? I ask because the Supreme Room is more in our price range and looks fabulous, but I'm a little concerned that we will hear the people in the other room. Do you recall that being an issue? Thanks!

The supreme room works wonderfully as a stand alone room. You won't hear anyone as the rooms are designed to face people away from each other. It certainly would not be an issue.

For what it's worth, we stayed in the main building, second floor, with an ocean view. No problem with any neighbor noise. The room was very spacious and had a great view of the grounds and distant ocean.

Agree that the Supreme rm is very private--you won't know your neighbors are there! Also very very spacious--one of the larger rooms we have stayed in.

Thanks to these and other great posts about St. Kitts and Ottleys, I just booked our honeymoon there for October! I'll be sure to post a report when I return!