We need more info, but the higher end upscale islands

Anguilla
St. Barth (not big on pools though)
Turks and Caicos

The above also have the best restaurants.

All islands have an upscale resort though.

Cap Juluca or Cuisinart, Anguilla
Little Dix Bay, Virgin Gorda (BVI's)
Caneel Bay, St. John (USVI)
Eden Roc or Isle De France, St. Barts
Amanyara or Parrot Cay, Turks & Caicos

Hi - we actually stayed at CuisinArt on our honeymoon - it was amazing, but we would like to try something other than Anguilla on this trip. Would you recommend St. Barts or T&C over Mexico (Zoetry or Rosewood Mayakoba)? We're flying from the East coast so the location of the Carribbean is easy. Please let me know what other info you might need to advise on this - thank you!!!

I personally prefer Turks over St. Barth.
St Barth has better restaurants, but the ones in Turks are outstanding anyway.

Turks has much better beaches and much better pools.

You get more for your money too at Turks out of the resorts.

High end resorts for you to check (depending on what you're looking for, different personalities)

Grace Bay Club (3 pools 1 with swim up bar)
Seven Stars (biggest pool from choices)
Point Grace (gorgeous pool Zen atmosphere)
Somerset (infinity zero entrance pool, lap pool with resistance)
Regent Palms (cool beach pod beds, swim up bar, tables and seats in the water, hot tub)
Gansevoort ( little deck islands with individual lounge chairs, South Beach vibe)

Amanyara is nice but it's a long expensive ride to all the great beaches.

A great vacation, feels like 2 in 1 would be a split, Parrot Cay with one of the above.

Restaurants you do not want to miss

Coco Bistro
bay Bistro
Coyaba


Also check out. Www.WhereWhenHow.com click on current issue, many pictures of everything Turks. Yu can also email and get a hard copy sent to you, you'd get it within 2 weeks.

Congrats on your #10!
Storm season in Carib pretty rainy in November usually
weather2travel.com Climate guides
might consider the "Blue Sky" ABC isles
out of the storm belt Hyatt Regency Aruba our fav.
luxurylink.com many other good options.
In fall we also go to Mauna Kea princeresortshawaii.com
for less rain great packages on priceline.com

Happy Hunting!

I'm the polar opposite of blamona - I much prefer St. Barths over the Turks & Caicos. For me the island has it all - very nice beaches, turquoise waters, a fantastic selection of restaurants, plenty of water sports, great shopping, excellent options in resorts, hotels and/or rental villas. For us it's as good a Caribbean location as it gets.

And, yes St. Barths over Mexico any day of the week.