Caribbean Islands Forums

Post New Topic

Recent Activity

View all Caribbean Islands activity »
  1. 1 Trip Report Credit Card-Carrying US Independent Travelers Go to Cuba
  2. 2 How to avoid nudity in St. Maarten.
  3. 3 Peterson
  4. 4 Trip Report In search of rum and revolution - Mr & Mrs Annhig go to Cuba.
  5. 5 Which Caribbean island to choose?
  6. 6 St.Lucia newbie
  7. 7 Trip Report aruba fun!!!
  8. 8 Anguilla - where to rent a car
  9. 9 Honeymoon destination help!!!!!
  10. 10 Antigua vs. Barbados vs. Jamaica
  11. 11 Turks and caicos
  12. 12 Aruba weather
  13. 13 BFF Trip, 3 girls, 7-8 days total. Suggestions???
  14. 14 Dominican Republic self drive tour
  15. 15 Turks and caicos
  16. 16 Cruise stop activities
  17. 17 Choosing an island for summer vacation
  18. 18 Jade Mountain
  19. 19 Honeymoon Help!!
  20. 20 Bermuda
  21. 21 Restaurant Suggestions
  22. 22 St. Martin: cost of transportation to Grand Case
  23. 23 Havana Cuba for 2 days
  24. 24 Mid-Twenties couple looking for a lively, gorgeous resort
  25. 25 Restrictions on US Military travel to Cuba?
View next 25 » Back to the top

Jamaica VS Puerto Rico

Jump to last reply

Hello fellow travelers!

My fiance and I are planning a 5 night 6 day trip for the beginning of June 2011. We are 26 and 29. We have been doing extensive research on which island to visit. We both love the outdoors (zip lining, jungle, waterfalls, snorkeling, etc) and also enjoy busy nightlife. After looking at every island possible we narrowed it down to Jamaica (either Montego Bay or Negril) or Puerto Rico.

I had my mind set on Jamaica and to my dismay I was hearing nothing but bad things...it's dirty, slummy, lots of crime, etc. Jamaica appealed to both of us because of the number of activities (Dunn falls, Rastafarian villages, Bob Marley Museum, zip lining, cliff diving) and because of the nightlife. Not to mention all the great All-Inclusive resorts that are available. The Iberostar Grand Rose Hall in Montego Bay was very appealing and a few Couples Only Resorts in Negril.

After hearing all the terrible things, someone suggested San Juan, Puerto Rico. With it being apart of the U.S. and basically offering most of the same things as Jamaica along with what they say is the best nightlife in the Caribbean we have been giving it a lot of thought. We were also looking for modern 4-5 star hotels in San Juan.

Anyways, we are still on the fence about both places. I would love to hear some feedback and hear what you have to say! Any comments, suggestions or experiences would be great! Thanks for the help!!!

17 Replies |Back to top

Sign in to comment.

Advertisement