hi, Tux! I'm so happy to see back posting on the forum again. Interesting to hear about the changing snorkeling conditions. When you headed back?

So sorry to hear about Waterlemon Cay! I just suggested it to someone else. It was so beautiful just a couple of years ago.

Where do you stay?

I guess I'm in the minority but I just got back from St. John. I didn't "love" it. I am not sure what it was. Cruz Bay is not the most enjoyable towns, although there are some very good restaurants (e.g. Waterfront Bistro, Asolare). There are some funky places to hang out in Coral Bay (e.g. Island Blues). The vistas are gorgeous. But I just felt that beyond that there was not much else going on. I stayed at Caneel so I have no complaints about my lodging. I think the weather may have put a real damper on things because it rained for 3 days that I was there. To each her own I guess.

Great to read a St John trip report! I am sad as we are not going this may for the first time in 4 years . We will be back for Thanksgiving for 10 nights. Little things really do change quickly there. The roundabout is pretty much done, new restaurants etc. We went to Vie's last time. Pretty beach and the chairs don't hurt either. Snorkelers saw a little seahorse there.

Sorry you didn't have a great time there, jecrow. From your post, I can see STJ may not be the most scintillating place. However, the low-key, not-much-going-on is probably why we love it. We are snorkeling fanatics so we really can't seem to get enough of STJ and the Virgin Islands generally. There never seems to be enough time for all the snorkeling or kayaking or hiking to all the spots we want to hit. We love the different places to eat out at and we enjoy cooking in too so we're always pretty busy and I think that makes STJ perfect for us. IMO,no place has to be perfect for everyone. ejcrowe, thanks! I'm hoping to get back for a quick visit in late May, but who knows. With this crazy economy, it'll probably not happen again until September. Kristen1206: we have a little cottage in the Coral Bay area which we have never rented out. If things don't improve though, we'll have to think about doing that. BTW, a great place to look for rental possibilities is VRBO or one of the many other local rental websites and then ask for opinions/experiences on forums like this one. brenandg: At least Miss Lucy and Vie's will be open again in November. The roundabout may be close to done but it's still causing traffic jams! It didn't help that some contractors stupidly parked on the road and blocked off a whole lane. We were lucky we only went into Cruz Bay a few times. We love Vie's, although, I have to admit it was relatively crowded this time around (@15 people). We met some terrific people from Maine who rented a house for a whole month. Can you imagine? A whole month! I have a house and I can't imagine the luxury of being able to stay for a whole month. Someday...

Great update on your fav island, Tuxedocat. I was there last June and loved it even more than on previous trips. do understand when folks say there's not a whole lot going on, but that is why i enjoy it.

We just got back last night from a week in St. John. We rented a villa above Fish Bay and got a great deal. It was a GREAT vacation. We had friends staying at the Westin and we all snorkled and hit different beaches each day. The only problem was that my 2 kids (11 & 14) and their two kids, (same ages) all came down with severe ear pain. It started about half way through the week and got worse and worse. None of our kids have ever had swimmers ear. I'm taking mine to the doctor this afternoon, and am assuming they have ear infections. Have you heard of this before? My friend who stayed at the Westin said she heard other people complaining of the same symptoms, including adults. Are any of the beaches known for poor water quality and bacteria? Just thought I'd ask since you've been there many times.
The trip itself was fabulous and we'd do it again in a heartbeat. I saw several turtles and they were my first ever. We've snorkeled in Hawaii, Costa Rica, St. Thomas and St. John and never saw this many fish. We loved the view in our villa and got a great last minute deal (VRBO).

Hi Krom - just wondering where you stayed? the specific name, if you know it? we are looking to book for july, family of 4 with two teens. would love a firm recommendation for a nice place, lovely view, A/C and a small pool would be nice. Also - I had the same ear problem in croatia a few years ago. Spent 2 weeks there swimming every day and by the end of the time there I had a terrific earache! It was horrible (kids were fine..) found out that it was an outer ear infection from the waters there. Took lots of drops , antibiotics, etc and next time we go anywhere water related will bring drops and swimmers ear medicine to be sure! good luck - curious what the doctor says .

tlangenbach,

We stayed at a villa called Sundancer. If you go to vrbo.com and enter number 71531 you can see it, and there is also a website at www.sundancer.com. The views were spectacular, and there was a small pool and hot tub (not super hot though). It's quite a drive to get there--about 3 miles from Cruz bay and lots of twisty turns, but great scenery. Someone from Cimmeron property management met us at the ferry dock and we followed her there. She gave us the tour and the keys. The 2 main bedrooms have an air conditioner, but the rest of the house is not air conditioned. There is a 3rd bedroom upstairs in a loft with a huge balcony and sliding door, so with all the windows open there was usually a nice breeze. My son slept up there. It might be a lot hotter in the summer--not sure how much. If you don't mind driving a bit to get to Cruz Bay or the northside beaches it's a great place to stay. We'd go back.
Regarding the kids' ears, my daughter has a regular ear infection and my son and the other family's 2 kids all have swimmer's ear. They still have ear pain, but supposedly it takes a while for the drops to work? Good luck with your trip and thanks for the reply. We'll be taking drops with us for prevention next time!

I am disappointed to hearthat even around Caneel/St.John the snorkeling is just about had it. We are going to Peter Island resort and while we are avid snorkelers we did not expect good snorkeling like caneel but hoped for average around Jost Van Dyke, etc, but I suppose it will really disappoint. we are going for relation but were hoping for 2 good snorkel outings in the week of R&R but it sure does not seem that is in the cards.

Just go BA-A-CK too, from a fantastic full moon week at Ajax Peak above Coral Bay. Never stayed at that end of the island before and it was great! View over the east end and out to the eastern BVI from one deck and North over Leinster Bay and Tortola from the back side. We also found it to be a much shorter drive to the beaches because we didn't have to drive through town. Yet going into Cruz Bay for dinner was easy. Went to the full moon party at Miss Lucy's-just OK. Too many people, wait staff harried. We still love Lucy's but will stay with the more relaxed atmosphere at lunch. Speaking of lunch-had fabulous grouper tacos at The Tourist Trap out near Salt Pond Bay. You have to go there to appreciate the scene.
Hidden Reef Eco Tours offers a fantastic kayak and snorkling excursion just beyond Hurricane Hole-calm waters, lots of coral and sponges and great guide, Matthew. We'll do it all again.