Caribbean Islands Forums

Post New Topic

Recent Activity

  • Announcement:
  • Recent Spam Attacks
    by mkataoka Fodor's Editor | Posted on Nov 28, 16 at 01:31 PM
View all Caribbean Islands activity »
  1. 1 Cuba for 6 Americans
  2. 2 Trip Report I WAS STOLEN BY A STAFF AT THE FRONT DESK OF ATLANTIS ROYAL TOWERS!!!
  3. 3 New Destination
  4. 4 Last min 5 night stay suggestion
  5. 5 Which island for first visit? April/May
  6. 6 St Lucia - Where to Stay
  7. 7 Bahamas help
  8. 8 Cayman VS Jamaica
  9. 9 Hilton Rose Hall Jamaica for toddlers -- how's the food?
  10. 10 Vacation suggestion, please
  11. 11 Best use of 800,000 Hilton points for family with toddlers?
  12. 12 Bitter End Yacht Club or somewhere else?
  13. 13 Good time of year to visit Turks & Caicos
  14. 14 ANTIGUA & DOMINICAN REPUBLIC CASINO SCAM ALERT!!
  15. 15 Best Itinerary - Brazil, Puerto Rico, Dom Republic and Cuba
  16. 16 aruba planning advice
  17. 17 Fun Family Lunch Spot in Anguilla?
  18. 18 Trip Report Thanksgiving Week in St. Thomas
  19. 19 Fun Ideas for Christmas Eve Family Dinner?
  20. 20 Transfer from Havana to Varadero
  21. 21 Atlantis Resort Bahamas
  22. 22 A few questions about Sonesta Great Bay
  23. 23 Barbados Beaches
  24. 24 Negril Jamaica- upcoming stay at Sandals Beaches resort
  25. 25 Peterson
View next 25 » Back to the top

Help me pick an island for my first Caribbean trip

Jump to last reply

I am looking for advice on picking which island to visit for my first time to the Caribbean in May. I’m going with my sister and we are both women in our early 30’s. I've done some research on Grand Cayman and St. John but would like other suggestions based on our interests.

Here’s what we are looking for:
-Excellent beaches (white sand, clear water) that aren't overly crowded
-Great snorkeling and/or scuba (I'm the only one that does scuba, so I would only do this once or twice, but we both love snorkeling)
-Tropical paradise/beautiful landscape (perhaps something similar to Hawaii, nothing that's barren or ugly once you leave the beach)
-Availability of other activities (for example, easy hikes, biking on the beach, horseback riding, watersports, gardens). We don't need our days to be packed full of activities, but don't want to sit on the beach for a whole week either.
-Safety is extremely important
-Moderately-priced accommodations close to the beach (don’t need luxury hotels but not looking for Motel 6 either)
-We do not want a place that is fast-paced, crowded, noisy, or dirty. We are looking for relaxation and quiet.

Which islands would be a good fit for us? Out of the places I've researched (Grand Cayman, St. John, and St. Lucia) and it seems like St. John meets most of our needs, but I'd like other suggestions before we make a decision.

10 Replies |Back to top

Sign in to comment.

Advertisement