Caribbean Islands Forums

Start a new topic Change Forum
Advanced search

Four Seasons Nevis vs. Carlisle Bay Antigua

Jump to last reply

It's a walk-off.

My wife and I have whittled down our options for a Caribbean trip this Spring, and now we have to choose between two resorts: Four Seasons Nevis and Carlisle Bay Antigua. Our AMEX travel agent has recommended these two, and we'll be getting the FHR benefts at both.

We are a young couple looking for a relaxing vacation with lots of time on the beach. We would prefer not to have too many kids around, but a few is OK. I think our travel timing (late May) will ensure that we're not swamped with families anyway.

We aren't planning on being too adventurous, and most days we'll probably spend on a chaise in the sand. However, we would appreciate the option of exploring the island beyond the resort, taking nature hikes, shopping, going out to eat.

In terms of watersports, we would like on-site access to sailboats, paddleboards, and snorkeling. We prefer calm, shallow water, as we've spent some time recently at places that have lots of wave action/current and we want a change.

We also want to go on a horseback trail/beach ride at some point. We are very into food, and we love big breakfasts (especially since they're free via FHR).

We love making use of the spa, too.

To give you a reference point, we went to Parrot Cay and Grace Bay Club this past fall, and we loved both, but we especially loved the upscale yet relaxed feel of Parrot Cay (and the Como Shambala spa was killer).

I think the FS is going to end up being cheaper on the front end, but we would be willing to spend more for Carlisle if it's worth the premium.

Any advice would be incredibly helpful. Thanks!

-PF

11 Replies |Back to top

| Add a Reply

Sign in to comment.

Recent Activity

View all Caribbean Islands activity »
  1. 1 Looking for deep sea fishing, beaches, culture (ALL CARIBBEAN SUGGESTIONS)
  2. 2 Aruba Beach Club - Eagle Beach
  3. 3 Cuba Opening Up
  4. 4 Trip Report Just back from The Somerset
  5. 5 BodyHoliday, St. Lucia or other wellness spa recommendations?
  6. 6 Late October Honeymoon in the Caribbean
  7. 7 Barbados/St. John/Turks/Puerto Rico/Curacao/
  8. 8 Advice needed: Caribbean island / beaches for small children/toddlers
  9. 9 ROMANTIC DINNER FOR VERY SPECIAL OCCASION- seeking advice
  10. 10 Sandals Resorts
  11. 11 Falmouth, Jamaica that bad???
  12. 12 Where is the most romantic place for dinner in Bermuda?
  13. 13 Best place for two single girls in early 20s?!
  14. 14 Trip Report Trip Report - Eastern Cuba 2006
  15. 15 Bahamas Out Islands OR Turks & Caicos for family of teens?!
  16. 16 Please help me decide to go to Cuba!
  17. 17 Cuba in 10 days
  18. 18 1st time to Caribbean/Turks & Caicos - suggestions
  19. 19 Turks/Caicos or Dominican Republic
  20. 20 Best Snorkeling near/in Punta Cana?
  21. 21 ISO recs for high-end and high-chair-friendly meals in St. Martin
  22. 22 Santo Domingo Day Trip from Punta Cana
  23. 23 Villa rental on St. John
  24. 24 Not impressed with Aruba, too touristy. Period. Are we out of luck?
  25. 25 Trip Report Just back from St. Maarten
View next 25 » Back to the top