Caribbean Islands Forums

Start a new topic Change Forum
Advanced search

Curacao vs. St Lucia vs Grand Cayman

Jump to last reply

DH and I are planning a vacation for late May and will be leaving from the DC area. We are in our mid-40s and are planning a romantic getaway. We are looking for a relaxing vacation, great beaches, good restaurants and some options for other activities (shopping is not a priority). We love to linger over breakfast on vacation and would love have an open air dining option where ever we go.

In the Caribbean, we've been to Barbados (Hilton), Aruba (Hyatt), and Antigua (Galley Bay). Last year we ventured away from the islands and went to the Mayan Riviera (Secrets Maroma). Of these, our least favorite was Aruba because the area was so built up.

We're currently considering Curacao (Hyatt) , St Lucia (Windjammer) and Grand Cayman (Ritz-Carlton). Here are our questions:

1. St Lucia - I know the island is beautiful but have heard mixed things about the beaches. Can anyone comment on what they are like? Also, any feedback on the Windjammer? I noticed that many of the villas have an open living area--are bugs a problem?

2. Curacao - Anyone have recent experience with the Hyatt? The tripadvisor reviews point to some issues with the beach--a dock running the length of the beach and beach in an inlet instead of looking out over the Caribbean. Does anyone know if this is the only beach area at the resort and if this is accurate? If so, this won't work as a great beach is really important to us.

3. Grand Cayman - The reviews of the Ritz are good but I was wondering how stuffy the hotel is. We're looking for something fairly low key. Also, any guesses on how crowded the beach will be this time of year?

Thanks for any help. As always, any other suggestions are appreciated.

9 Replies |Back to top

| Add a Reply

Sign in to comment.

Recent Activity

View all Caribbean Islands activity »
  1. 1 Carry on size Bahamas
  2. 2 Turks and Caicos - Best Time to Book Accomodation
  3. 3 Vacation Ideas
  4. 4 St John March, where to stay
  5. 5 The right adults-only resort
  6. 6 Cuba - Questions about Phone/Internet/Currency
  7. 7 Jamaica vs. Barbados
  8. 8 1st time to Caribbean/Turks & Caicos - suggestions
  9. 9 Cupecoy Beach
  10. 10 Tips for bahamas
  11. 11 Trip Report St. Martin/Nevis Trip Report
  12. 12 Seven Mile Beach Questions
  13. 13 First time to Puerto Rico need advise please
  14. 14 condo / villa with kids, on the beach
  15. 15 Trip Report My trip report from 10/23 - 11/1/14 - St. John USVI's
  16. 16 Bay Gardens Beach Hotel in St Lucia
  17. 17 Barbados with two kids under 4.
  18. 18 walkable hotels
  19. 19 Colony Club Barbados OR Sandals Great Exuma Bahamas????
  20. 20 Trip Report Back from San Juan
  21. 21 St Thomas
  22. 22 Cheapest excursions in Punta Cana?
  23. 23 St Thomas need condo advice and trip plans
  24. 24 Grenada - Coyaba vs. Flamboyant
  25. 25 Aruba Restaurants
View next 25 » Back to the top