Caribbean Islands Forums

Post New Topic

Recent Activity

View all Caribbean Islands activity »
  1. 1 50th Birthday Trip in Nov
  2. 2 Calling Beach and Island Lovers .. Need your Advice!!..
  3. 3 Late May Trip
  4. 4 St Thomas Hotel by Airport
  5. 5 would it be safe to drive from negril to port antonino?
  6. 6 West Bay or Seven Stars
  7. 7 Trip Report St. Thomas is dangerous
  8. 8 Cheers to Beers!
  9. 9 Where To Go Post Xmas- Mid Jaunary for under $4G
  10. 10 any advice about the Cayman Islands?
  11. 11 New Years Eve / St John
  12. 12 Trip Report St Lucia Trip Report 2014 Bay Gardens Beach Resort
  13. 13 Island Choice
  14. 14 Aruba Car Rental
  15. 15 If we loved Cayman...
  16. 16 Harbor Island ?? Anyone
  17. 17 Caribbean Christmas with teenagers
  18. 18 For the bluest water and whitest sand?
  19. 19 Trip Report Anguilla Trip Report & Photos 6/26-7/3 2016
  20. 20 HELP! St Croix or Cancun
  21. 21 Good time of year to visit Turks & Caicos
  22. 22 aruba planning advice
  23. 23 Post Christmas to Mid January Getaway For Two
  24. 24 Woman, alone, islandhopping
  25. 25 Marigot, Rodney, or Soufriere?
View next 25 » Back to the top

Couples Negril vs Secrets St James Montego, Help me decide!

Jump to last reply

After spending the last few vacations in TCI, Mexico and the DR, my husband and I would like to return to Jamaica. I've narrowed it down to these two resorts. I'm hoping someone who's been to both of them will respond.

After some research, the PROS of Couples seem to be: better food, better beach
CONS of Couples: long drive from airport, rooms getting tired looking/rundown.

Pros of Secrets: Very clean, new; lots of dining options ; great service
Cons: Beach manmade, on the small side, food mediocre

I'm sure we'd have a fine time at either resort but the ambience/entertainment would tip the scales for me in making a decision. What I really appreciate when I'm on vacation is outdoor eating options with a beautiful view and local entertainment with an island vibe-in this case Reggae. My major complaint with Couples Swept Away was the lack of Reggae music....american music being piped in....and no steel bands in sight.

Secrets St James describes outdoor entertainment nightly with fire shows, local music etc but I've really no idea what Couples Negril offers other than the passing vendors on the beach who will play you a song for a tip.

Can someone whos been to both weight in please? thanks

4 Replies |Back to top

Sign in to comment.