Caribbean Islands Forums

Start a new topic Change Forum
Advanced search

Carlisle Bay or Cotton Bay?

Jump to last reply

My husband and I and our 2 and 6 year old daughters are traveling this August for our 10th anniversary. Our main criteria is a resort with a nice room (we do spend time in our room), nice pool and beach facilities (while we like the beach, we are not really ocean people and prefer to swim in the pool), with an excellent kids club. Since it is our anniversary, we would like some down time from the kids but do want to experience the vacation with them as well. Ideally, we would also like a kitchen, but are toying with the idea of not having one. I don't want a sprawling resort - I like to be able to walk easily to the beach, room, pool, Kids Club, etc.

My reservations about Cotton Bay: beach not great, rooms with shutters only = bug bites, some bad reviews on trip advisor, not much feedback here on fodors, kids club (only 2 hours per day for the youngest) looks great for the 6 year old!

Carlisle Bay: no kitchen (except in the Carlisle Suites, twice as expensive), kids club all day for the youngest too, much more expensive than Cotton Bay ($1075 per night all inclusive rate vs $270-344 per night)

I am open to other suggestions but seem to be limited by the 2 year old. Looked at FDR, LOVE the idea of a vacation nanny but decided the resort itself, especially the rooms, looked a little shabby. Most recent resorts we have traveled to include: Four Seasons Costa Rica, Half Moon Jamaica, and The Somerset - T & C.

3 Replies |Back to top

| Add a Reply

Sign in to comment.

Recent Activity

  • Announcement:
  • Fodor's 100 Hotel Award Winners Announced
    by Emily_D Fodor's Editor | Posted on Sep 17, 14 at 01:05 PM
View all Caribbean Islands activity »
  1. 1 Turks & Caicos
  2. 2 7 days solo...Cuba or Puerto Rico, guys???
  3. 3 Memorable anniversary dinner on St. Thomas?
  4. 4 Restaurants in St. Barth's?
  5. 5 Travel to the Caribbean the week before Christmas
  6. 6 Trip Report Long Island Bahanas
  7. 7 All Inclusive in Caribbean or Mexico?
  8. 8 Honeymoon Help- Caribbean Destination with Walk-in Snorkeling & Nightlife
  9. 9 Need Caribbean island/hotel suggestions for February trip with 2 year old
  10. 10 St. Bart's-- how can I get La Pinta vanilla rum?
  11. 11 Which carribbean island to chose.. dilema's...
  12. 12 DIY Wedding for Two – Can I pull this off without a Wedding Planner?
  13. 13 Punta Cana excursions
  14. 14 Girlfriends All Inclusive Resort Punta Cana or Mexico
  15. 15 Which Sandals Jamaica is the best
  16. 16 Van rental for 8 in Puerto Rico
  17. 17 Stop Jet Ski's in Anguilla
  18. 18 Restaraunts & Rental Cars in Aruba
  19. 19 Aruba suggestions
  20. 20 Trip Report I got robbed in St Maarten - St Martin on the French side
  21. 21 Nassau
  22. 22 Antigua - First Trip - Which Beach and Which Bed ?
  23. 23 LIAT Air
  24. 24 cheapest christmas airfare by destination
  25. 25 Trip Report Lobster, Heat & Banged Up Feet - Another Awesome Exumas Adventure
View next 25 » Back to the top