Caribbean Islands Forums

Post New Topic

Recent Activity

View all Caribbean Islands activity »
  1. 1 St. Lucia or elsewhere?
  2. 2 Grand Cayman Ritz or Sandals Barbados
  3. 3 Cuba in November
  4. 4 would it be safe to drive from negril to port antonino?
  5. 5 50th Birthday Trip in Nov
  6. 6 Calling Beach and Island Lovers .. Need your Advice!!..
  7. 7 Late May Trip
  8. 8 St Thomas Hotel by Airport
  9. 9 West Bay or Seven Stars
  10. 10 Trip Report St. Thomas is dangerous
  11. 11 Cheers to Beers!
  12. 12 Where To Go Post Xmas- Mid Jaunary for under $4G
  13. 13 any advice about the Cayman Islands?
  14. 14 New Years Eve / St John
  15. 15 Trip Report St Lucia Trip Report 2014 Bay Gardens Beach Resort
  16. 16 Island Choice
  17. 17 Aruba Car Rental
  18. 18 If we loved Cayman...
  19. 19 Harbor Island ?? Anyone
  20. 20 Caribbean Christmas with teenagers
  21. 21 For the bluest water and whitest sand?
  22. 22 Trip Report Anguilla Trip Report & Photos 6/26-7/3 2016
  23. 23 HELP! St Croix or Cancun
  24. 24 Good time of year to visit Turks & Caicos
  25. 25 aruba planning advice
View next 25 » Back to the top

Best ISLAND for a relaxing, no hassle anniversary

Jump to last reply

Please help me pick a spot for me and my wife's 5 year anniversary. We have 3 young, active boys - who will not be joining us - and my wife wants some serious R & R. Here's an idea of what we want:
We honeymooned in Grenada and loved it (except for a couple of complaints, which I will mention in a moment); however, we are the type to try something new, rather than return to the same island. What we liked about Grenada were the beaches (esp. Grand Anse and La Sagesse), the complete lack of crowds, the mountainous green interior, and the friendly people. What we did not like about Grenada was the remoteness (had a difficult time on the connecting flight and took 2 days to get there), the restaurants (too few and most with good but not great food, though all incredible views), and just generally getting around (a few days we rented a car and had an adventure, a few days we walked TOO much for my wife's liking - this time we really are not looking for adventure OR a lot of walking other than causal strolls).

So, the first requirements are an island with direct flights from the states. No connections in the Caribbean, please. This rules out some of the more remote, exotic locales, but we are willing to trade that this time in return for easy access.

Second, we want easy access to good food. AI would be great for convenience, but we are open to dining out as long as it's easy to find and get to great restaurants. This is where I really need help, as I don't know much about the food on many islands.

Third, a beautiful location (duh, it's the Caribbean). For the wife, that requires beaches that are beautiful, walk-able, and swim-able (calm). I like the same, but also require greenery and interesting topography. It doesn't not have to have mountains, but no flat islands, please. It does not have to have a rain forest, but a little more than just palm trees, please.

Fourth, nice accommodations. As this trip is primary for R&R we may spend a lot of our time at our resort. (My wife specifically wants to "feel pampered".) So, we are looking for a place you really don't want to leave. The quality and quantity of pool(s) is secondary to the rooms, baths, beach, and staff. This is a romantic trip, and the lodging should reflect that. And we do NOT require any bars, or party atmosphere. In fact, the less the better. In Grenada we stayed at the Coyaba Resort and loved it. Something similar would be great. For what we have in mind, I think a resort would be preferable to a private villa.

Firth, a reasonable price. I know this is VERY relative. I'm aiming for $750-1000 for 5 nights lodging. 5 years ago we paid about $1500 for 8 nights in Grenada. This is flexible (rated 5th for a reason). But if the entire island is pricey we might prefer a more reasonably priced island. Also, if the island predominantly uses a different currency please let me know so I can consider the true costs.

Primarily I need help picking the right ISLAND. Any resort recommendations are appreciated, but I feel confident in finding those once I find the right island.

THANK YOU in advance for all help.

19 Replies |Back to top

Sign in to comment.