Asia Forums

Start a new topic Change Forum
Advanced search

Mosquito repellent (DEET vs Picaridin) - 2010 topic

Jump to last reply

Hi,

I've just spent most of the day reading on DEET and Picaridin (two most effective substances against mosquito bites) and since this topic have not been brought up since '08, I wanted to share what I found and see what others had to say on the subject.

One of the most interesting sites I've found was: http://cfpub.epa.gov/oppref/insect/index.cfm (it lists all of the Insect Repellents) - notice the View All Results on the bottom.

According to the site, products with Controlled Release can protect you for much longer periods of time at lower chemical doses. For example, 20% controlled release DEET lasts 11 hours, whereas 98.3% DEET (max available) in OFF only lasts 10 hours.
Note: Picaridin max is 20%

Just so there is no misconception, they are both chemicals.
In both cases, strength of chemical does not increase strength of protection, just duration. (based on CDC)

Deet Pro: Lasts longer - up to 11 hours vs Picaridin max of 8 hours.
Picaridin Pro: Less irritation, easier to apply to face w/o causing eye itching.
Deet Pro: Time proven (1946) where as Picaridin is a incumbent (1990, on sale in 01).
Picaridin Pro: Odorless, where as Deet had an odor unpleasant to some.
Picaridin Pro: Will not melt plastic at higher concentrations.
Picaridin Pro: Provides protection against tics at lower concentration. Deet doesnt start offering tic protection until 25%.

Interesting links:
http://www.cdc.gov/ncidod/dvbid/westnile/RepellentUpdates.htm
http://amcequipped.blogspot.com/2009/06/picaridin-vs-deet-face-off-of-buzzer.html

Point of interest: Seems that US and Australian Army use 35% DEET
http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m0PDG/is_1_3/ai_113650073/

Another topic of my concern was availability overseas:

In my case I am in Japan, and max DEET available is 12% & Picaridin is not sold at all.
Solutions: International shipping with Amazon.com (route I am taking) or Ebay.

8 Replies |Back to top

| Add a Reply

Sign in to comment.

Recent Activity

  • Announcement: Writers Needed for Morocco Guidebook
    by Emily_D Fodor's Editor | Posted on Apr 11, 14 at 05:51 PM
View all Asia activity »
  1. 1 Jewellers in Sector 18 Noida
  2. 2 Trip Report April in Bangkok, again!
  3. 3 3 1/2 week trip to Japan advise please!
  4. 4 driver&business assitant&guide in Shanghai
  5. 5 Trip Report Karen and Tom - a romantic Vietnam getaway: ENGAGED!!!
  6. 6 Getting down to details and welcome advice: Tokyo
  7. 7 Haneda to Narita Layover : Need advice
  8. 8 Japan night bus
  9. 9 Recs for Tokyo hotels
  10. 10 Living in Singapore Questions
  11. 11 Thailand - Koh Samui vs Koh Tao
  12. 12 Hua Hin or another family friendly beach?
  13. 13 Trip Report Bangkok, Luang Prabang, Luang Say, Chiang Rai, Singapore (but no Siem Reap)
  14. 14 Help..Want to hire a guide/driver for Golden Triangle
  15. 15 12 day split between Beijing and Shanghai
  16. 16 Please help me plan 3.5 weeks in South Korea
  17. 17 Problems at 12,000'
  18. 18 GOING TO SE ASIA , NEED HELP
  19. 19 Sixteen Day in South Korea
  20. 20 osaka to kobe frrom ship to ship
  21. 21 Spring trip to Tokyo and Kyoto -10 days
  22. 22 Best Time of Year to Visit Ko Samui/Krabi (Weather)
  23. 23 Which Putu in Bali????
  24. 24 Biting the India bullet...well, maybe...
  25. 25 Japan, japan
View next 25 » Back to the top