Asia Forums

Start a new topic Change Forum
Advanced search

Hong Kong: Mandarin Oriental or Island Shangri La?

Jump to last reply

Hi All,

I'll be staying in HK for three nights this summer (first time there), and have narrowed down my hotels to two options: the Mandarin Oriental and the Island Shangri-La.

On paper, I prefer the location of the Mandarin - namely that its close to star ferry, LKF / Soho and the peak tram. On the other hand, I think aesthetics of the Island Shangri-La are much more unique (compared to the big chain hotels we get in the states), which is appealing. I also like the outdoor pool (given how hot it will be). I know either of these top notch, so I am really just nit picking here.

In sum, I think I like the vibe of the Shangri-La but the location of the Mandarin. I'd like to know if anyone has experienced both of these and has a preference, or if those familiar with the city think that the Mandarin's location is significantly better than that of the Shangri-La.

Also: I get corporate rates at these hotels, which is why I'm not considering any of the other lux properties in the city (so while I appreciate anyone's enthusiasm on another hotel, I'm really only focused on these two!).

Thanks in advance for any thoughts!

3 Replies |Back to top

| Add a Reply

Sign in to comment.

Recent Activity

  • Announcement:
  • Fodor's Go List 2015 Has Been Announced
    by Emily_D Fodor's Editor | Posted on Dec 19, 14 at 05:08 PM
View all Asia activity »
  1. 1 Buying loose sapphires in Sri Lanka
  2. 2 Southern India itinerary help needed
  3. 3 A Thailand holiday vacation 9 years in a row!
  4. 4 Hanoi driver wanted
  5. 5 Your favorites in south India & places you'd probably not recommend
  6. 6 Trip Report vietnam and laos
  7. 7 narrow down destinations, Japan 2 weeks in April
  8. 8 2nd location on the beach
  9. 9 Help: 24 hours to change decision for award flight BKK-SFO
  10. 10 Safe to buy Sapphires in Sri Lanka
  11. 11 Thailand - Food recos
  12. 12 Seoul - Cuckoo rice cooker
  13. 13 First Time Solo Trip To Thailand Itinerary
  14. 14 Laos for the backpacker
  15. 15 The best way (or place) to see Mt. Fuji while staying in Tokyo
  16. 16 Single parent traveling to Thailand with a 4-yo son
  17. 17 Amazing Samurai Armor Exhibition
  18. 18 Thailand Hotel
  19. 19 Which Section of Great Wall? And add visit to Ming Tombs?
  20. 20 Best country to visit 1st time in Southeast Asia
  21. 21 Honeymoon in Thailand
  22. 22 One Week in Asia, First Time Trip to Asia
  23. 23 Can you HELP with figuring out United Miles and how to get them SF-Bangkok?
  24. 24 Bangkok: Shangri-La, Penninsula, Mandarin Oriental
  25. 25 Elephants in Northern Thailand
View next 25 » Back to the top