Air Travel Forums

Start a new topic Change Forum
Advanced search

TSA Eliminates Backscatter X-Ray Nude Body Scanners

Jump to last reply

More good news:

http://www.wired.com/threatlevel/2013/01/tsa-abandons-nude-scanners/

Unfortunately, they are getting rid of only the backscatter x-ray machines, sold by Rapiscan, but not the millimeter-wave body scanners. So, we're still saddled with slow, highly expensive, and not very effective technology (*). But the good news is that X-rays are known to be dangerous; the only scientific debate is how safe the possible exposure levels are (**). So, it's good to get rid of those. Millimeter waves have not been well studied, but at least we don't know of any reason why they'd be dangerous.

The decision is apparently due not to abstract scientific safety concerns, or cost effectiveness, but because Rapiscan couldn't get their software right in time to do the automated target recognition. So, this is a win for privacy, as only a computer will see the "nude" images. I'm sure politics had nothing to do with this at all. (***)

(*) The whole "enhanced imaging device" nude scanner thing was driven by the Underwear Bomber, but the scary thing is that al Qaeda has already used a rectum bomb in an assassination attempt:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abdullah_Hassan_Al_Aseery

(**) With a properly functioning and calibrated scanner, assuming the X-rays are absorbed uniformly by the body, the dosage level is tiny and poses extremely low risk. The concerns are that the backscatter X-ray frequencies tend to be absorbed concentrated in and near the skin, increasing the dose; that the machines might not always be maintained or calibrated properly (and TSA forbids agents from wearing radiation badges, reducing safety in an effort to make people feel safe); and that the software controlling the scanning might fail, resulting in a concentrated X-ray dosage.

(***) http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2010/11/23/fear_pays_chertoff_n_787711.html

2 Replies |Back to top

| Add a Reply

Sign in to comment.

Recent Activity

  • Announcement:
  • Fodor's Go List 2015 Has Been Announced
    by Emily_D Fodor's Editor | Posted on Dec 19, 14 at 05:08 PM
View all Air Travel activity »
  1. 1 Do we need a 3 hour layover at DFW if coming from overseas?
  2. 2 AA Business Class seats from DFW to CDG and back to ORD - quality?
  3. 3 TAP Portuguese Air
  4. 4 Using a "Fake" Location for Better Flight Prices???
  5. 5 The beggining of the end of Airbus A380?
  6. 6 Oxford to Athens and back to London
  7. 7 Time needed between flights?
  8. 8 Air canada checking correct VISA
  9. 9 Health and Safety for time left sitting on the tarmac.
  10. 10 Anyone used webjet.com?
  11. 11 Which One World Airline to Use: American, Cathay Pacific, JAL?
  12. 12 90 minute change at heathrow terminal 5
  13. 13 Unsealed pills ok for airlines?
  14. 14 Delta has changed my flight three times (so far)!
  15. 15 redeeming dividend miles
  16. 16 Keeping AA miles alive
  17. 17 Taxis at CDG......
  18. 18 why hasnt price of airfare dropped?
  19. 19 United/Lufthansa code share--can't reserve seats until departure??????
  20. 20 Trip Report KLM stinks
  21. 21 Driver's License Expired and TSA
  22. 22 Trip Report Gimpy Geezer and Wife Fly Air France A380 Premium Economy from DC to Europe
  23. 23 Please help: Singapore to Tahiti to Hawaii to Singapore
  24. 24 Name on passport differs from air ticket
  25. 25 Korean Air Executive Resigns Post After Halting Flight Over Snack Service
View next 25 » Back to the top