Air Travel Forums

Start a new topic Change Forum
Advanced search

Help choosing an airline, please

Jump to last reply

Hi all, this is my first post on this forum, and am very much looking forward to all the objective advice I'm sure I'll receive!

We need help choosing an airline for our first trip to Europe. The last time I had a long haul international flight was a hundred years ago on Varig to Brazil; I was much younger then, excited, and couldn't have cared less about comfort :-). Alas, time has marched on and now such things are important to me, so here I am asking for your advice.

We live in Nashville, and have easy access to all major airports in the US, so I've been focusing on flights leaving from the NYC area as they seem to be best price wise. Oh--our destination is Rome (FCO).

We've narrowed the list down to four, and I'd very much like your advice/opinions on which YOU would prefer. Our goal is to get to Rome comforably, in as large an economy class (or preferred economy) seat as possible, with as few layovers as possible (less opportunity for lost luggage). Here's what we've come up with:

UA: pros: we can book straight through from Nashville, possible to upgrade to "comfort" economy, earlier arrival in Rome, heavier carry on luggage allowance. Cons: "comfort economy" still a bit smallish (not a true "premium"), longer layover in NYC.

Turkish Air: Pros: Beautiful looking/comfortable premium economy; cons: longer flight with later arrival in Rome, layover in Istanbul with only one connecting flight to Rome (if we're late we're stuck in Turkey), limited carry on allowance, and not so great reviews.

Alitalia: Pros: direct flight to Rome, affordable/attractive premium economy seating; cons: bad reviews, limited carry on weight

TAP portugal: Pros: super inexpensive coach fares to Rome, standard coach seat sizes seem larger than most; Cons: layover in Lisbon limited, concern for luggage transfer

Of these four, which would you choose? Are there others I may not have thought of? Thanks so much for your kind replies!

19 Replies |Back to top

| Add a Reply

Sign in to comment.

Recent Activity

View all Air Travel activity »
  1. 1 Health and Safety for time left sitting on the tarmac.
  2. 2 TAP Portuguese Air
  3. 3 Which One World Airline to Use: American, Cathay Pacific, JAL?
  4. 4 Do we need a 3 hour layover at DFW if coming from overseas?
  5. 5 90 minute change at heathrow terminal 5
  6. 6 Unsealed pills ok for airlines?
  7. 7 Delta has changed my flight three times (so far)!
  8. 8 redeeming dividend miles
  9. 9 Keeping AA miles alive
  10. 10 Taxis at CDG......
  11. 11 why hasnt price of airfare dropped?
  12. 12 United/Lufthansa code share--can't reserve seats until departure??????
  13. 13 Trip Report KLM stinks
  14. 14 Driver's License Expired and TSA
  15. 15 The beggining of the end of Airbus A380?
  16. 16 Trip Report Gimpy Geezer and Wife Fly Air France A380 Premium Economy from DC to Europe
  17. 17 Please help: Singapore to Tahiti to Hawaii to Singapore
  18. 18 Name on passport differs from air ticket
  19. 19 Korean Air Executive Resigns Post After Halting Flight Over Snack Service
  20. 20 To select a seat or not>
  21. 21 Using half of a RT ticket
  22. 22 United Flight- Houston/Tokyo
  23. 23 Anyone used webjet.com?
  24. 24 what if we do not continue flight?
  25. 25 Trip Report First time on 787 Dreamliner - great, mostly!
View next 25 » Back to the top